resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Is It Time to Rethink Mental Illness? (Pt. 1)
Invariably, patients will ask their chiropractor about depression or various mental illnesses. Some practitioners will reflexively offer a cervical adjustment, suggest St. John's wort or contemplate a referral to a specialist.
New Relationships, Old Trauma: AOM & Other Healing Strategies
Being in love is one the most beautiful and enjoyable experiences. Most of us are willing to pay almost any price to have that experience, and still often find it elusive or fleeting. Navigating the ups and downs of loving relationships are often challenging — even for the most psychologically balanced among us.
Bill With Confidence: Learn What to Collect
Q: I am trying to understand what I may collect from my patient when there is insurance. Do I have to accept the amount allowed by the plan or may I collect up to my billed amount? Please note, I am not a member of any insurance plan.
The Visual Error Scoring System: A Concussion Tool
Postural stability and oculomotor function are the most easily recognized physical indicators of neurologic motor dysfunction associated with concussions.
Why I Quit Doing House Calls
My father was a chiropractor who did house calls, so when I became a DC, I figured doing house calls was part of the job. My March article recalled my experience as a small boy, accompanying my dad while he went to patients' homes to treat them.
A Major Role in Back Pain: The Multifidus
Back pain affects roughly 80 percent of the population at one time or another and is one of the leading causes of doctor visits.
An Unexpected Diagnosis: The Result of Lacking Communication
A couple years ago I had a case that showed me the importance of open communication between health practitioners. We need to show up with less fear, and let go of our judgments so we can do better for the patient.
Clearing Blocks: A Way to Improve Cosmetic Acupuncture
As a Five Element acupuncturist who teaches facial acupuncture classes nationally, I was surprised to learn that one of the basic principles I was taught in school is unfamiliar to most acupuncturists.
Women's Hormones: A Western & Eastern Perspective
Sometimes it may seem that you require a degree in medicine to understand hormones and how they function.
Eczema & Acupuncture: A Sound Solution (Part 1)
Eczema affects approximately 3.5 percent of the global population and is one of the most common skin complaints seen by dermatologists.
Balancing Spring Challenges
As the winter months come to a close and warmer spring weather appears, patients may begin to present with new challenging pattern presentations.
News in Brief
ACA Adopts New Governance Model; ACA 2017 Awards; CCA Helps Calif. DCs "Share the Love"; $1 Million to Help Advance the Profession; D'Youville Raises the Bar on Anatomy Education; ErRatum.
Is the New Medicare Reporting Exemption Right for You?
What you've heard is not a rumor – there will be exemptions for providers of Medicare patients, with no penalties assessed for offices that do not do Quality Payment Program (EHR, PQRS, MACRA and MIPS) reporting.
A Daily Strategy for Heavy-Metal Detox
In modern society, we are constantly exposed to heavy metals such as cadmium, lead and mercury. These heavy metals have no essential biochemical roles in our body, and conversely, can cause us a great deal of harm if they build up to toxic levels.
Raditation & Your Smartphone: Is it Worth the Risk?
If radial arteries could talk (and in my experience they can to some extent), they would say, "Step away from the smartphone." At least that is the message I am receiving loud and clear as I feel the pulses of many patients.
An Integrated Approach to Chronic Pain
Findings from a unique Medicaid pilot project in Rhode Island involving high-use Medicaid recipients from two health plans were recently presented to the state's Department of Health, demonstrating stellar outcomes with regard to medication use, ER visits, health care costs and patient satisfaction.
Creating Good Business Buzz
What do patients really think about working with you? Rarely do you hear the whole truth. Those who improve may be candid in their gratitude.
Give Yourself the Digital Advantage
When you see this article in the print version of this issue and swear you read it already, don't be alarmed: you probably did. That's because by that time, the May issue will have been available online in digital format for three weeks.
Universal Design: Principles & Practice
In many respects, universal design serves as the core of ergonomics. It's also a good tool to use when designing a return-to-work program for injured and/or ill patients. Let's take a closer look at universal design and why it should matter to you and your patients.
Taking the Chiropractic Message to the Press
"There is no better place on earth to have a news event," the National Press Club boasts, and it's easy to understand why: Every year, the 108-year-old Washington, D.C.-based organization hosts countless press conferences on the hottest topics impacting America and often the world.
May, 2014, Vol. 14, Issue 05
CAMTC Sunset Hearings Reveal Concerns
Prostitution, human trafficking, law enforcement and operational questions come to light at legislative hearings.
By Kathryn Feather, Senior Associate Editor
In the midst of its Sunset Review process, the California Massage Therapy Council (CAMTC) finds itself addressing concerns from law enforcement agencies, city and county leaders, as well as a former board member, all urging the California legislature to sunset - or put an end to - the CAMTC and put massage therapy regulation under the California Department of Consumer Affairs.
When the CAMTC was established in 2009, many saw this as an opportunity for the profession to show it could govern itself, harness the estimated millions in potentiall annual licensing fees and provide a model for other states to follow. However, as the sunset review process continues, this experiment could be coming to an end.
Senate Bill 731 (passed in September 2008) established a two-tier voluntary certification system that allowed a massage therapist to practice lawfully throughout the state without being subject to city or county ordinances. It also established the CAMTC, a private nonprofit organization acting as the regulator of massage therapy certification.
Prior to the passage of SB731, massage therapists in California were subjected to the ordinances enacted by individual cities and counties providing for the licensing and regulation of the business of massage. It was a patch work of various regulations many therapists were eager to see disappear as they were often paying multiple fees to practice in more than one city or county.
The sunset review process is a normal assessment of state regulatory programs, established to determine whether they should be continued by the legislature. The process for CAMTC began in 2013 when the group began drafting its sunset review report and continued on March 10, 2014 with a joint hearing before the Assembly Business, Professions and Consumer Protection Committee and the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
Without legislative action, the CAMTC in its current form is set to sunset - or cease to exist - on December 31, 2014.
Law Enforcement Concerns
The CAMTC has had to garner support from law enforcement and city and county officials from its inception. CAMTC CEO Ahmos Netanel said the group has "a robust communication protocol with the majority of local jurisdictions. In December 2013, we reached out to more than 400 police chiefs and sheriffs and offered a no-cost training for their officers. So far, we have received more than 120 requests for our specialized training. In the past 90 days, we trained approximately 500 law enforcement officials, including police chiefs, sheriffs, FBI agents and district attorneys."
However, the League of California Cities was quick to trot out legislators, mayors, council members and law enforcement agencies to urge the legislature to sunset SB731 and the CAMTC, as they believe this process as it stands lends to the proliferation of illegitimate massage establishments, prostitution and human trafficking.
The League is seeking a restoration to local control over massage therapy businesses. The League's Legislative representative, Kirstin Kilpitcke, outlined several priorities in her testimony at the joint hearing, including having a state agency oversee certification and licensing of massage professionals rather than a nonprofit; requiring owners of massage establishments to be responsible for what occurs in their businesses; modifying the language that authorizes local governments to regulate massage businesses to the extent a jurisdiction "uniformly" regulates all other business professionals; and clarify the statue so that local governments can charge fees to recoup the costs of enforcing the statue.
These issues stem from the fact that under the current legislation, CAMTC is only responsible for certified employees and owners. If an owner of a massage business is not certified, CAMTC can take no action against that owner and local governments have, "their hands tied and cannot regulate these businesses," according to the League. The League also said that, "because cities and counties do not uniformly regulate business professionals, the existing law effectively prevents the regulation of the massage industry."
In her testimony, San Francisco Supervisor Katy Tang expressed concerns with SB 731, saying certain provisions leave the city unable to regulate and manage massage establishments and that the city has lost significant oversight authority. Tang said many establishments closed by the city have since reopened under the CAMTC certification process.
Prior to the hearing, staff for the joint committee issued 19 recommendations related to CAMTC and its operational structure. CAMTC addressed much of these recommendations in its testimony before the committee.
In his testimony, CAMTC board member Michael Callagy, a former deputy police chief, said that, "CAMTC recommends that it be given the authority to implement a voluntary registration program for establishments. Establishments that are not registered with CAMTC would be subject to whatever regulation a local jurisdiction would see fit to impose, regardless of whether all massage providers are certified or not." Callagy said the funds for such a program would come from existing CAMTC financial resources.
Also in response to the issues presented regarding increased local control, Callagy testified that, "CAMTC agrees that legislation should be passed which strikes a better balance between the needs of massage professionals and local control. For this reason, it has proposed legislation in 2014 that will provide local government with the explicit authority to address establishments that use massage as a subterfuge for prostitution and supports CAMTC voluntary registration of massage establishments."
Netanel said he "found the issues the committee staff raised to be sensible and predictable" and that "CAMTC is in the process of formulating a response."
In his testimony, CAMTC former board member and ABMP Chairman Bob Benson acknowledged some successes from CAMTC but sided with the staff's recommendation that "a strong argument can be made for the continuation of some form of professional regulation: statewide regulation is more efficient, consistent and the norm across the majority of states."
Benson, who served as the initial Vice-Chair and participated in 51 of the 52 board meetings held during his 2009-2013 tenure, stated in his testimony that, "the model of voluntary certification by a nonprofit organization was a good one for a five-year transition from a confusing hodge-podge of local massage regulation, often administered by individuals with little understanding of the health benefits of massage therapy and limited capability to assess whether someone seeking to provide massage was in fact well prepared to do so."
But, Benson went on to state that, "unfortunately, CAMTC approaches to managing its affairs have not matured. With no state funds provided, CAMTC initially had to make several expedient choices about cobbling together resources. As financial stability was secured, though, senior management turned a deaf ear to suggestions for building a stronger, lasting management structure."
"Weaknesses in CAMTC's underpinnings keep emerging. The staff background report cites numerous areas of CAMTC administrative weakness:
Benson went on to state that, "despite CAMTC spending over $500,000 a year for outside lawyers, a continuing backlog of hundreds of applications still awaits CAMTC attorney action to issue proposed denial or revocation letters and final letters of determination."
"The organization lacks a seasoned Controller/COO. Information systems are inadequate for needed controls." To prove his point, Benson cited the original report submitted by CAMTC to the legislative committee. Benson said it was, "riddled with errors on matters as fundamental as the number of certified individuals by category and the status of those who had been referred to PSD ... and it took CAMTC staff five weeks to produce corrected data."
"That's a portrait of an organization lacking sufficient administrative control. And now, on top of these deficiencies, CAMTC is seeking to shoulder additional responsibility for approving massage establishments and inspecting massage schools. It's delusional," said Benson.
Benson instead urged the committee to:
"The state board model works well in scores of other states. It is time for that model in California," said Benson.
CAMTC is currently formulating its response to the staff recommendations and concerns cited by those providing testimony during the legislative hearings. According to Netanel, April 29th is the last date for the sunset bill to be out of the committee and CAMTC is waiting to receive the proposed bill language.
In the meantime, there are currently four bills before the state assembly that could potentially impact the massage therapy profession (AB 1904, AB 1147, AB 1747 and AB 2739).
The purpose of AB 1147 is to "enhance the competency requirements for persons seeking certification as a massage practitioner by requiring an applicant to take and pass a massage and bodywork competency examination in addition to the 250 hours of education currently required." Assembly Bill 2739 would extend the provisions of the existing law until January 1, 2019.
With passionate testimony from both those advocating the success of CAMTC and those advocating for sunset and a state board, several scenarios remain. The legislature could sunset CAMTC and the state could revert back to the patch work pre-2009 regulations. The legislature could extend existing law to 2019 and keep CAMTC in operation as is or with various modifications found in the four bills currently before the legislature. The legislature could make licensure mandatory and put the process under state control as suggested by Benson and many local government officials and law enforcement agencies.
"CAMTC is proud of its successes and we look forward to working with the police chiefs, the local communities and other stakeholders to do great things for the massage profession and the public," said Netanel.
Massage Today will continue to report any updates to the sunset review process as details become available. To contact your legislature and let them know about your experience with CAMTC, visi www.leginfo.ca.gov/ to find the representative for your area. If you wish to contact the committee directly, visit http://abp.assembly.ca.gov/membersstaff or call (916) 319-3301.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.