resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Building Kidney Yang and Jing
Kidney yang, if we include mingmen fire, is the energy and heat source for the whole body. Jing is the essence of yang, and is stored in the kidney, extraordinary channels, and in the bone marrow, which in TCM also includes the brain.
A Very New Year: It's Time to Track
As we enter 2017, we find "affordable care" is not so affordable for many individuals. They are discovering what employers learned long ago: Health care is expensive – and keeps getting more expensive.
Change on the Horizon? New White House Spells Shift in Health Care Policy
On the morning after Election Day, many in our country were surprised to learn that not only did the Republican nominee win the White House, but also that the House of Representatives and the Senate remain under GOP control.
The Key to Recovery
Starting in the 1970s and developing over a decade of assessment and improvement, the South Bronx's Lincoln Recovery Center staff refined the method of using five basic ear-points, which became the NADA protocol for the treatment of addiction.
Herbs for Digestion: The Power of Bitter
Many cultures (and indeed herbal clinicians) around the world have long respected the role of bitter herbs and foods for promoting digestion.
What Are Prebiotics – and Why Should You Care? (Part 1)
In previous articles, I spoke about the different kinds of fiber and their effects, and the potential risks of taking probiotics without also consuming prebiotic soluble fiber (PSF) in foods and/or supplements [see August & October 2016 issues].
Case Study of Benign Hand Tremors
Patients without degenerative diseases causing tremors are often given the diagnosis of essential tremors, for which treatment options are limited to lifestyle changes and medications.
Increase Your Practice Income With Retail Products
With only so many hours in a day, there is a cap on the revenue an acupuncturist can generate by way of appointments. Once your appointment book is filled, you can't really add more without burning yourself out.
The Mysterious Divergent Channels
The divergent channels are among the most mysterious entities in all of Chinese medicine. They are rarely mentioned, lacking reference in modern TCM study, and rarely used within popular Chinese medical treatment.
Losing Your Mind? Try Coconut Oil
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is currently the 6th leading cause of death in America according to the CDC. It affects over 5 million Americans and 50 percent of nursing home residents (2014), and is projected to spike to 16 million by 2050.
Top 2017 Health & Fitness Trends
We really did sign up for a career of learning and development. Now that you have built a strong foundation of your manipulation skills, nutrition base, movement assessments and business knowledge, it's time to keep up with the American College of Sports Medicine's 2017 worldwide health and fitness trends.
MD-DC Affiliations Under Fire
I am George P. McAndrews, lawyer for the chiropractors in the Wilk, et al., v AMA, et al., antitrust suit that resulted in an injunction against the AMA and others, banning them from interfering in lawful professional relationships between medical physicians and doctors of chiropractic.
Your Patients With Cancer Need You
It was a chilly Minnesota morning in March 1999 when she asked to speak to me alone. My then-busy chiropractic practice wasn't built for much privacy, but I quickly scooted the 60-some-year-old, white-haired patient to my exam room, as the open adjusting area was buzzing with excitement.
An Education in Stroke Risk and Chiropractic
Dr. Steven Shoshany's ninth appearance on "The Dr. Oz Show" may prove to be his most significant, as he addressed questions related to the death of Katie May, who suffered two strokes in February 2016, hours after her third visit to a chiropractor for what she described in a Twitter post as a pinched nerve in her neck experienced during a photo shoot days earlier.
Scope of Chiropractic Practice: Time for Change?
The University of Bridgeport, College of Chiropractic Student Government Association sponsored a panel discussion on Oct. 25, 2016.
Acute Locked-Back Syndrome: Cause and Correction
As we all know, occasionally a patient will present with acute-onset low back pain with or without a precipitating incident. A distinguishing feature of the presentation is visible lateral antalgia, both standing and walking.
Scar Reduction With Acupuncture & Microneedling (Part 1)
Applied correctly, modern skin needling techniques can form part of a holistic treatment and incorporate the principles of Chinese medicine.
Clinical Outcomes & Safety for TCHM
The practice of Traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine (TCHM) may appear archaic to those who misunderstand the theories and principals that guide it. In fact, TCHM continues to evolve and new systems are consistently being discovered and applied within the tradition.
February, 2014, Vol. 14, Issue 02
Is Hours and Hours of Education Really the Answer?
By Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB
A small but influential group of people in our field have wrapped their brains around the idea that we must increase the number of entry-level education hours to elevate our standing with the public and get massage therapy incorporated into mainstream healthcare. This is only a theory and one that is not substantiated by evidence.
Improving working conditions and opportunities for massage therapists is an important goal for our stakeholder organizations to pursue. However, this single-minded focus on jacking up the number of training hours while ignoring the quality of instructional design and delivery is not only foolish – it is dangerous.
It is time to take a good look at the ramifications of such a decision. A curriculum with more clock hours is going to cost all parties involved more money. Tuitions will have to be raised if schools are to provide longer programs. That will make it more difficult for prospective students to afford massage school. Those receiving Federal student loans and other financial assistance will graduate with more debt. Is more debt a good thing? Usually not, except in the case of politicians and government.
The operative question is: will the graduate of a longer program, burdened with more debt, be able to go out into the field and make significantly more money than a graduate of today's programs? This is where the theory breaks down. Are the massage franchises going to automatically start paying more to graduates who have more hours on their school transcripts? Massage Envy currently has a corporate policy that does not allow individual franchises to pay a newly-hired therapist more – even if they have years of professional practice experience. It's doubtful more training would convert to better wages.
Are hospitals, chiropractors, clinics, spas and cruise ships going to raise the compensation paid to massage therapists because they have more hours of training? Will the public pay 50% more for massage because the therapist has, say 750 hours instead of 500? Will the marketplace support increased prices for massage? The real-world perspective is a resounding "NO."
Consumers are already backing away from massage according to AMTA surveys. So, who will be served by raising hours? New students will have to deal with the logistics and greater expense of being in school for a longer span of time. Facing an already shrinking pool of new applicants, schools will be further challenged as they are forced to provide more classroom space, develop new curricula and pay for more faculty and administrative staff hours. This kind of mandate could push another group of small proprietary massage schools off the cliff. The only institutions that can afford to absorb these expenses are the for-profit career colleges and the publicly-funded community colleges. If this were to occur, it would put more of the true lineage-holders of massage education out of business. That would be a tragic loss to the future of massage therapy.
Who wins here? One might think the public would benefit from a better, more consistent massage delivered, but more training hours in and of themselves do not a better therapist make. I can attest to that as I have received massage from the 2,000-hour wonders in Canada. My most disappointing massage experiences have been in Canada. I am sure there are great therapists north of the border but they are no more common than here in the U.S.
Will more hours taught by today's untrained or under-qualified instructors produce a better therapist? More poorly-taught hours could actually make a worse therapist by exposing students to poor role models over a longer period. Hours are not the answer to providing more consistent and effective massage services to the public.
And what about the much-touted "safety" issue? Aren't these laws in place to protect people from being injured? Well yes, but the fact is the incidence of actual harm from massage therapy is miniscule. But wouldn't more hours create a safer therapist? Anecdotal information from one of our major membership associations shows it may be just the opposite: the higher the number of education hours, the more insurance claims against practitioners. Armed with more tools in their utility belts, it appears that "advanced" therapists may be more likely to get themselves into trouble.
Some are just positive that if we raise our hours, then we will be accepted by mainstream healthcare. If history is any indication of how that works, there is clear evidence that an increase of few hundred hours is not going to open any doors. The medical establishment is not about to let in any practitioner group that does not have a rigorous college-level training requirements.
Case in point: the nursing field is on track to eliminate traditional diploma-level programs in hospitals and community colleges and require a bachelor's degree for all registered nurses. By 2015, the entry-level credential required to become a physical therapist will be a doctoral degree! If they won't hire nurses without a bachelor's, are they going to hire high school grads who finish massage school with even 900 or 1200 hours? Maybe – but only at a level comparable to CNA's or physical therapy assistants. Is working at the lowest levels of the medical pecking order an upgrade? Is that the recognition so many people's egos seek? Oh, that's right, there will be "benefits." Right, maybe if you are full time.
Anything we do hours-wise to gain acceptance by the allopathic medical community will mostly punish ourselves. The only real hope of gaining acceptance by the powers that be is to deliver consistently high-quality, professional massage services to the public. It is public demand that will bring us acceptance and that public trust must be earned.
Saddling entry-level therapists with more debt to work for no more money will prevent them from taking the ongoing continuing education that creates a successful therapists in our system. Remember, we are first-door providers with full autonomy. No gatekeeper sits on our heads. The public has direct access to us. We should be teaching entrepreneurship, professionalism and competency – not just a relaxation routine, enhanced with "deep tissue technique" which seems to have become a way to charge by the pound for pressure, usually un-artfully applied. It is time we provide a solid foundational education for all therapists and honestly advise that post-graduate specialization should be part of their career plan.
We do not have a chance of being accepted by the medical profession in general until we can deliver the goods. Unfortunately, our current system of massage education cannot reliably produce that at any hour level. Until we have a competency-based education with a standardized skill base, taught by properly trained teachers, we are going to continue to contract as a field. We're never going to be taken seriously as long as we keep producing self-congratulating projects like the MTBOK and ELAP that amount to "Bridges to Nowhere."
Fortunately, the solution is not only within our grasp, we have already created it. Sadly, it is being left twisting in the wind by our major stakeholder organizations. Tune in to the March issue for a new proposal to solve this problem. And bring your kites!
Click here for more information about Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.