resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
We Get Letters & E-Mail
Let's Restore Integrity to Health Care – Starting With Us; MDs Offer More – So Can We.
Qigong to Empower Our Youth
Qigong is an ancient form of exercise and meditation used to promote longevity and health. This practice has traditionally been used by adults to balance the body through mindfulness, focused breathing and gentle movements.
Putting Public Health Into Action: Thinking Globally, Acting Locally
The Chiropractic Health Care section of the American Public Health Association (APHA) met at the 141st APHA Annual Meeting and Exposition in Boston late last year, and it was another triumph for chiropractic and its public health advocates.
An Alternate Method For Choosing The Right Formula For Your Patients
A constant question for us in the clinic is when to make adjustments and when to stay the course. A patient comes in and says, "Things are the same as last week."
Increased Breast Cancer Risk: Another Implication of High Cholesterol
In addition to being a known risk factor for heart and cardiovascular disease, recent studies have highlighted the link between high cholesterol and increased risk of breast cancer. Breast cancer is the second most common malignancy in women after skin cancer.
An Introduction to Evidence-Based Clinical Practice - Again
One of your patients is in for treatment and catches you off guard by asking you a question about a news article she recently read. It seems that a new intervention for back pain was found to reduce the rate of serious side effects by 50 percent.
News in Brief
Parker Announces Executive Director of Parker Professional; Athletic TIPS Program Getting Financial Support; ANJC Award Recipients Named.
Ask and You May Receive
A friend of my mother has had a problem with her ears for almost 20 years. Whenever the wind blows, it sends shooting pain through her jaw. She has seen any number of medical specialists over that time, but with no relief.
Gaining an Independent Occupational Code with the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
One of the most important national activities currently taking place in relation to the development of the field of AOM profession is the Department of Labor's Bureau of Labor Statistics' (BLS) revision of the 2010 Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) system.
The Many Faces of Cervical Compression
When evaluating the neck, there are any number of orthopedic tests to be considered.
New Knee, New Pain (Part 2)
The patient presented to the chiropractic clinic with symptoms of genu varum and pain on the medial aspect of the tibiofemoral joint.
The Urinary Bladder Official
The Bladder Official is known as the Official Who Controls the Storage of Water. In Western medical terms, this organ collects the urine excreted by the kidneys.
Betraying Patients and the Profession
Imagine flying from New York to Paris on a jumbo 747. Your thoughts are on your vacation and experiencing the City of Lights. Midway over the Atlantic Ocean, you overhear the flight attendants talking in muffled voices.
Peer Points: Spreading The Word
Pedram Shojai describes his venture into Traditional Chinese Medicine as a journey led by various "mystical experiences." Shojai decided to change the course of his career when he looked deeper into the basics of TCM.
Preserving the Natural Resources and Culture of Chinese Herbal Medicine
As the world experiences unprecedented population growth and ever-increasing ecological pressures, the topic of preserving Chinese medicine's natural resources has attracted steadily increasing attention from practitioners.
Embracing the Light
Four years, ago I was diagnosed with a labral tear in my hip that was excruciating and "required surgery" according to an orthopedic surgeon. I tried everything and although the symptoms had mostly abated, I had to give up Yoga practice and everything that could exacerbate the tear.
The Deficiency Myth
If you went to the same kind of medical school I did and took the same kind of licensing exam I took, you were trained to seek out and expect to find primary deficiencies here in the U.S.
Acupuncture Ambassadors: A Chat with Leader Anthony M. Giovanniello, MSAc,LAc
When you first meet Anthony Giovanniello, you realize he's a humble practitioner, yet is bursting with a type of dedication that you can't help but be overwhelmingly inspired by.
The Importance of Staying Focused
Our world is so full of over stimulation and constant information. We live in a fast paced, ever-changing society. If you seek you will receive.
Why Stretching Doesn't Work
Like most chiropractors, a good part of my day is spent working with sedentary office workers who spend eight to 12 hours a day glued to a desk chair in front of a computer.
Common Disorders of the Temporomandibular Joint
The evaluation and management of craniofacial pain is a complex endeavor, which often encompasses the presence of temporomandibular joint disorders.
Climbing the Ladder of Opportunity (Part 1)
President Obama spoke of building "ladders of opportunity" in his State of the Union and Inauguration addresses.
Using Facial and Scalp Acupuncture To Treat Neuromuscular Facial Conditions
As a practitioner and instructor of facial rejuvenation acupuncture I have gotten many calls over the past 10 years from individuals seeking help for various conditions affecting the facial muscles, nerves, and overall function of the face.
Gallop Confidently Into The New Year
Happy New Year! As you may know, this is the year of the Wooden Horse. I received a wonderful gift for Christmas. It is a beautiful glass sculpture of a horse, by Luili Gong Fong, a Chinese artist.
Look, Listen and Learn to Code
Study of the Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) Evaluation and Management (E&M) coding system can leave a doctor of chiropractic a bit confused. The description of the five new-patient and five established-patient examination codes takes up several pages in most coding books. The degree of detail and charts used to describe the codes can be overwhelming.
November, 2013, Vol. 13, Issue 11
It's Time to Stop Chasing Rainbows
By Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB
Would you rather be told the truth, even if it were unpleasant – or would you prefer to hear a fabricated storyline that sounds great and matches what you wish for? Many of the "stakeholder" organizations in the massage therapy field are betting that you want the second option and are hoping you can't tell the difference between the two.
"Truthiness" may be commonplace on the political landscape, but we're being bamboozled by the leaders of our field who are pushing an overblown agenda for the massage therapy profession. It's a scenario impossible to achieve from our status quo and could actually cause more damage than good.
Instead of addressing the inherent weaknesses in massage therapy education and practice, these organizations are ramping up efforts to move our field into mainstream healthcare. We're getting served up messages that highlight the expanded opportunities, increased earnings and greater professional recognition awaiting rank-and-file therapists when we get to the "promised land" of integration with Big Medicine. To be sure, massage folks are hungry for better pay and more respect, but the powers that control our healthcare delivery system are not interested in letting any other practitioner groups into the game – especially when there are reimbursement dollars on the table.
But wait a minute ... doesn't the Affordable Care Act have language that mandates coverage for licensed practitioners of complementary and alternative therapists? Yes, but Section 2706 is on the chopping block, as the medical, hospital and insurance lobbies are gearing up to get this provision removed as Obamacare goes into effect. Even if that part of the law stands and is implemented, massage therapists would be at the lowest level of the totem pole. National certification for our field is meaningless and irrelevant here.
We'd be in a system in which reimbursements for massage services would be low, wages paid to massage therapists in medical facilities would also be low (probably not much more than what techs are paid to clean bedpans) and we would lose the most important thing we have today: autonomy.
Being able to treat who we want, using the techniques we choose, with the opportunity to address the whole person (and not just a symptomatic complaint) is a major part of what has made massage therapy successful in the marketplace. Let's not kill the goose that laid the golden egg. Consumers are looking for alternatives to the rushed, impersonal and reductionistic care that is the norm in our medical mainstream. Sacrificing our freedom as practitioners for an empty promise of a brighter future would be a tremendous loss. It's time for our massage organizations to stop chasing rainbows, get honest with themselves and their constituents, and work on solving the real problems limiting our progress as a profession.
Massage therapy is not ready for prime time because we still lack: 1) a consistent scope of practice; 2) consistent standards in massage education; and 3) requirements for teacher training. Until we handle this (which will take at least a decade), the quality of services delivered to consumers on a daily basis will remain random and often ineffective. The growing body of research on the therapeutic effects of massage is a good thing, but it is merely theoretical. By itself, research will not advance the profession; the entire corps of 300,000 massage and bodywork therapists must be able to provide quality treatment on a regular basis.
Research data comes from specific aspects of massage performed under controlled conditions. Because of the serious training and skill deficits that exist, many therapists are unable to provide competent massage that meets the expressed needs of the client. Our massage organizations should fund a research study on the hallmarks of effective treatment and investigate the percentage of therapists who are actually able to deliver a treatment to these standards. And contrary to the "public safety" mantra hammered into our heads as the reason we have subjected ourselves to state massage regulation, there is little actual harm done in the practice of massage therapy. We do not have a safety problem – the crisis is with our deliverables.
In the August 2012 edition of this column, I wrote about the "Seven Deadly Sins of Massage Education." I'm sorry to say these sins are being repeated daily by a sizeable number of our schools and no organization or state agency is holding them accountable. The Alliance for Massage Therapy Education recently completed the first phase of its National Teacher Education Standards Project, which was to define the Core Competencies for Massage Therapy Teachers. We now have the model for teacher development, but the "Big Three" organizations in the massage field – ABMP, AMTA and FSMTB – have refused to contribute a dime to the Alliance to move this project forward. It's shameful.
Instead, these same organizations have spearheaded and funded two major initiatives that have taken huge chunks of time, money and expertise, and have failed to produce results that are actually usable to improve the quality of massage education and practice. I'm referring here to the Massage Therapy Body of Knowledge (MTBOK) and the still-in-process Entry Level Analysis Project (ELAP). In both cases, the organizations came together under a feel-good banner of cooperation, but dropped the ball when it came time to supervise these efforts to ensure they remained on track.
The MTBOK was supposed to produce the definitive set of knowledge, skills and abilities an entry-level massage therapist needs to practice safely and effectively. The eight-member task force that did the actual work overshot that mark by a country mile. And despite a prodigious follow-on effort by AFMTE to remap the competencies and make them relevant to entry-level massage education, the final product has been put on a back shelf for a five-year period by these organizational "stewards."
If one useless project wasn't bad enough, we now have the same organizations forcing the ELAP upon us. This time, the entire project was conceived in secret and there was no opportunity for therapists and educators to put their names in the hat to be considered for the hand-picked work group. In addition, the public comment opportunity that was provided by the sponsoring organizations was so long and hard to navigate that it's likely only a handful of people outside of the work group itself have been able to grasp the recommended curriculum map as a whole. Since it's impossible to give an educated opinion on individual standards or competencies without seeing how they relate to the entire document, the feedback from the field cannot be considered valid.
Many of the standards contained in the draft version of the ELAP are significantly beyond or outside of what is generally considered entry-level education in our field. It appears the sponsoring organizations are using the ELAP (as they did with the MTBOK) to push massage therapy into a framework whereby it can be accepted by the medical mainstream, rather than identify and set standards based on what actually exists today. This is not a virtual-reality game, my colleagues ... this is our lives, our careers, our profession – and the 5,000-year-old lineage of a healing art. Would you give up all this for a feeling of greater self-esteem?
We can raise the number of entry-level education hours to another arbitrary number, but will that increase the earning potential of new massage school graduates? I doubt it, but it will most certainly increase their student-loan debt. (I will expand on this in my next column.) Will more hours, poorly taught, result in the delivery a better or safer massage to the public? Highly unlikely. Membership organizations like ABMP and AMTA are in the business of attracting and retaining members. Therefore, they benefit from serving up fantasy pictures of the profession to encourage people to join and renew. Who wants to hear that most massage therapists have short career spans and don’t earn much money? That’s a guaranteed buzz-kill!
For their parts, FSMTB and NCBTMB are in the testing business, even though they cloak their endeavors in the garb of public protection. Their revenue is dependent on how many people take their exams and the money bags have shifted in the past four years away from NCB to FSMTB. For every six new therapists who enter the field, five leave. That revolving-door scenario means a constant supply of new test-takers. Do the math.
And what about dear, lonely COMTA? One of the hallmarks of a fully-fledged profession is having a specialized accrediting agency for that field that is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. COMTA is just that, but it's lost in a sea of six other agencies that accredit massage schools and programs. In most fields, there is just one such agency and all schools are required to be accredited by it. That's how consistent standards are held and enforced.
COMTA is essential to the development of a bona fide massage therapy profession, but it, too, has gotten the orphan treatment from the Big Three. In the past, AMTA pledged to provide financial support to COMTA "in perpetuity." That sounds like forever to me, but the AMTA Board of Directors yanked its commitment in 2008. Since then, COMTA has struggled to grow its market share of massage schools in the shadow of much larger and better-funded accreditors.
COMTA has one of the best templates for entry-level education: its Competency-Based Curriculum Standards. All COMTA schools are required to uphold these standards and they would provide a solid basis for all massage programs. We did not need the MTBOK and ELAP to reinvent the wheel when we already had a proven model to guide and improve massage education.
The Massage Therapy Foundation is AMTA's latest darling, to the tune of about $500,000 year in financial support. AMTA has pledged to support the Foundation "in perpetuity," which sounds really good until you remember how it treated COMTA. Who doesn't love research? It's beneficial, as I indicated above, but it can also be an elegant distraction that shifts our attention away from the unpleasant realities of the massage therapy field as it exists today.
As long as these organizations continue acting in their self-interests, putting forth puffery projects that boost their image and refusing to focus on solutions to the real problems, the status quo will persist. I'm reminded of the final courtroom scene from the 1992 movie "A Few Good Men," when the Navy JAG officer played by Tom Cruise is cross-examining the hardened Marine colonel played by Jack Nicholson. With his back pinned to the proverbial wall, the colonel shouts at the young attorney, "You want the truth? ... You can't handle the truth!" When it comes to the future of massage therapy, we want the truth and we can handle it. Stakeholder leaders, be advised.
WOW – This is my 80th column. Thank you all for your support, feedback and comments. The Holidaze are upon us. Try to remember these holidays are about more than shopping.
May we be reading this column in Massage Today again this time next year, healthier, happier, more prosperous and in a more peaceful world. And to all, a good night!
Click here for more information about Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB.
comments powered by Disqus