resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
The Case for Immunization
As long as I have been a chiropractor, I have seen many in this profession oppose vaccinations. Indeed, it has often been taken as a "given" that to be a principled chiropractor requires a curmudgeon's willingness to hold aloft that banner of opposition.
To The Finish Line With the Help of TCM
When acupuncturist Eddy De Smedt pursued a career in Traditional Chinese Medicine, he knew he wanted to make a difference.
Chiropractic Research in Review
Predicting Pain With Disability in Office Workers; Traction Approaches for Discogenic Cervical Radiculopathy; Intra-Articular Gas Bubbles Following Manipulation; Nonresponsive Chronic Ankle Sprains: Think Tendon Rupture.
The Tao of Gender
If you think gender is as simple as having a new client check off the "male" or "female" box on your intake form, we hope this article will expand your understanding and thus the reach of your health care.
Lime Jello on Morphine
Taste is in the eyes... actually the mouth... of the beholder. My food preferences have changed, lightening from the food of my youth. My parents loved heavy eastern European cuisine and I loved it as a child. Now I enjoy leaner, healthier whole foods.
Sports Science: What's in That Drink?
Athletes frequently ask me what the best liquid is to drink during exercise – water or a sports drink? Water provides the necessary hydration, but unfortunately, it lacks the key nutrients to aid in performance and recovery.
Correcting Pelvic Rotation Around the Long Axis: Adjustment Protocol
The pelvis can be considered a ring that can misalign on the sacrum rotating around the long axis. The following is a description of an adjustment that helps to correct sacroiliac rotation around the long axis.
Managing Today's Fertility Patient
I recently received an email from one of my fertility patients: "Got my lab results back. FSH is 11, AMH is 0.7. My doctor said these numbers aren't good. I guess I'm infertile. Just as a thought. Just set up an appointment to speak with an adoption agency."
Dr. George Goodman and His Legacy to Logan University
Those who knew him called him a revered leader, a visionary and one of chiropractic's biggest advocates. George A. Goodman, DC, Logan University's sixth and longest-serving president, passed away on Sept. 9. He was 70 years old.
Managing Patient Expectations About Acupuncture
Last year, I attended the Pacific Symposium in San Diego for the first time in six or seven years. It was the 25th anniversary of this event, and on one evening there was a panel discussion with the title; "What is Qi?."
Jingei Diagnosis: An Effective and Powerful Diagnostic
I graduated from the Kotatama Institute under the direction of Drs. Masahilo and Katsuharu Nakazono in 1984. As a student, I was exposed to the practice of most of the various theories and modalites of Oriental Medicine.
Simple Ways To Find True Happiness
Patients in our clinics are always seeking happiness. As their health advocate, we need to ensure we inform them that in order to find happiness, they have to make sure to identify what makes them happy in the first place.
CMT & Stroke Risk: Myth vs. Fact
By now, most of you have probably heard that the American Heart Association recently published a statement regarding the association between cervical dissection (CD) and cervical manipulative therapy (CMT).
Commingling Money: 12 Questions for the ACA About the CHAMP / NCLAF Merger
The American Chiropractic Association recently announced it was merging the National Chiropractic Legal Action Fund and the Chiropractic Health Advocacy and Mobilization Project into a single entity that will support both legal and legislative actions.
AOMA Strengthens Leadership Team
AOMA Graduate School of Integrative Medicine, a leading college of acupuncture & herbal medicine, announced the appointment of Donna LaPoint Hurta, MBA as the new VP of Finance & Operations this Fall.
Healing With TCM at San Quentin State Prison
For the prisoners at San Quentin State Prison, life-sentences are the reality of every day life. It is not often that prisoners get the opportunity to use alternative medicine to deal with common ailments they encounter behind bars such as, depression, anxiety and pain.
Communication 101: Please Explain Yourself!
Twice this past week, I overheard conversations about chiropractic. As you can imagine, it is a topic my ears naturally pick up. In both cases, a patient was talking to a friend about their experience with a chiropractor.
Pulse Diagnosis: What We Know
I am still finding pearls of wisdom from the books and papers that I inherited from my pulse diagnosis mentor Jim Ramholz.
A Commonly Missed Spinal Fixation: The Upper Lumbar Spine (Part 2)
As mentioned in part 1, using a flexion-distraction table is a great way to unlock this particular fixation. You have found the stuck segment. You have determined whether it is unilateral, midline or bilateral.
The Wonders of Light Therapy: An Interview with Wes Burwell
I first met Wes Burwell in 2011 when he was teaching a class on light. Since then, every time I hear him speak, his understanding of the benefits, function and capacity of light has evolved.
Essential Orthopedic Testing: Tests That Involve Standing on One Leg
Since these tests have a common mechanism of performance (standing on one leg), there are differential diagnostic concerns during testing. The tests cannot be completely isolated from each other for performance.
Uncle Sam Needs You (Part 2)
Where chiropractic care has been used in the military health services, it has been deemed very successful.
February, 2013, Vol. 13, Issue 02
Fear Avoidance and the Issue of Chronic Pain
By Nicole Nelson
According to the American Pain Foundation, an estimated 50 million Americans suffer from chronic pain each year. Let's take a closer look at those suffering with chronic non-specific pain (CNSP) and explore how fear may be partly responsible.Specifically, this discussion will attempt to shed some light on how fear might perpetuate the pain experience without the presence of any musculoskeletal problem. Although the pain these clients feel is very real, it is distinct from those suffering from biophysical causes of pain, such as infections, tumors, osteoporosis, spondyloarthropathies and stepping on a nail.
Current understanding of pain neuroscience suggests that pain is a multi-dimensional experience that involves sensory, emotional and cognitive components.3,13,18,21,26-28,32 Likewise, the way the brain interprets and processes these components can vary pain intensity. It seems pain may involve more than structural problems, making our job as massage therapists a bit more intricate than addressing leg length discrepancies or elevated shoulders. A review of more than 900 studies involving back and neck pain concluded that psychological factors play a significant role, not only in chronic pain, but also in the etiology of acute pain — particularly in the process of transition to chronicity.13
The Fear Avoidance (FA) model, originally presented in the early 80's, is a psychological model that accounts for why certain clients may make the leap from acute to chronic pain. FA suggests that it is overly fearful individuals that wind up suffering with chronic pain, to the degree that they avoid seemingly benign movement patterns so as to protect themselves from further pain.23 The model theorizes that there are essentially two pathways an individual can take after suffering from an incident of acute pain. The first and more functional pathway suggests the individual perceives the pain as a non-threatening experience, daily activities are likely continued with a reasonable level of protection and a functional recovery ensues. The other path involves catastrophizing, where the individual perceives the injury as very threatening and develops a "worst case" outlook.4,7,21
According to the model, the nociceptive system becomes persistently active which leads to an extension of pain beyond the time frame of normal tissue healing. The worry associated with doing more harm leads to an avoidance of activity which can eventually cause further de-conditioning, and in severe cases, depression and isolation.30,32 In essence, these clients have lost confidence in their body's ability to withstand a physical challenge to the area they associate with their pain. Multiple studies have set out to examine the relationship between pain-related fear and it's potential to increase pain perception and delay recovery.2,3,12,32
The researchers have found some traits among those that exhibit fear avoidance:
So, how do we apply this knowledge to an actual client? By recognizing those with fear beliefs and behaviors, we can tailor our suggestions and therapy accordingly. Above all else you must help fearful clients understand that they are not helpless victims of pain, rather they are active managers of pain and do have a great amount of control.26,31 Generally speaking, this includes exposure to current biopsychosocial pain theory, getting them to move better, more often, as well as including positive lifestyle changes such as improving nutrition, reducing stress and optimizing posture. The list below includes a few specific ideas collected from the literature that will help shape your treatments to those exhibiting FA and experiencing CNSP. This list is hardly exhaustive, but should serve as a jump off point for you to study and explore treatment ideas which will complement traditional massage methods.
First, seek out the right practitioner. After bouncing around from practitioner to practitioner looking for answers, your FA/CNSP client is probably feeling extremely anxious about the source of their suffering and is starved for an explanation. If this is the case, help them seek out pain specialists that utilize a comprehensive treatment approach which incorporates cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). This network of professionals will help your client realize that their pain is not necessarily a tissue problem, but one that is perpetuated by an interaction of physiological and psychosocial factors.
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) attempts to alter FA behaviors, emotions and beliefs.22,31 This is commonly done through teaching the impact that thoughts and emotions have in maintaining pain as well as teaching stress management techniques, problem solving, goal setting and activity pacing. CBT can be performed in a group setting to reduce costs and allow the therapist to share successful cases of alternative thought and behavioral patterns from other group members.
Second, try to encourage meditation and mindfulness. It is believed that catastrophizing accounts for 7% to 31% of the variance in pain severity.26 Improving the client's mindfulness has been shown to be an effective approach to pain management, likely by interrupting the thoughts of a doomed outcome.6,16,17,27 Mindfulness has been defined as, "awareness that emerges by way of paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally to the unfolding of experience moment by moment." Proponents of practicing mindfulness exercises, such as mediation, theorize that a mindful state is mutually exclusive of one that is busy catastrophizing, which involves interpretation, conceptual processing and judgment.27,28 Simply put, when one is mindful, one cannot have a doom and gloom outlook.
The third concept to keep in mind is that hurt does not mean harm so encourage them to move. One must consider that well intended medical professionals that are unfamiliar with psycho-social and behavioral perpetrators of pain, may have actually exacerbated your client's fears about movement and exercise (i.e. "let your husband carry your purse, it's too heavy for you" or "be extremely careful when getting up.") Naturally, flare ups as a result of too much activity is a legitimate concern for many with chronic pain; however, exercise has repeatedly been shown to be an effective pain management strategy.1,5,10,14,25,29,33 It is worth mentioning that these clients will feel discomfort when increasing their levels of activity, particularly when they have been leading sedentary lives. That said, a graded exercise plan is indicated and should be encouraged as the client will eventually adapt to increased levels of activity. I generally advocate clients begin this process by consulting with an individual with clinical exercise experience. If they are apprehensive about this idea, suggest they perform something they enjoy doing, perhaps walking (de-conditioned clients might do best by walking in a pool.) Recommend they walk 3 to 4 days per week for a length of time and speed that is challenging but not exhausting. Propose they add five additional minutes to their walk each week.
It is widely accepted that chronic pain sufferers exhibit deficits in proprioception.19 It has been observed that chronic back pain patients no longer consider their back as being a part of them and do not feel that the back can be controlled automatically.18 Lorimar Moseley's research has shown that sufferers of chronic low back pain have been found to have difficulty delineating the outline of their back when asked to complete a drawing of "how it feels."12 It is also possible that the varied alterations in trunk muscle recruitment patterns evident in CNSP patients may be a manifestation of a disturbance in body perception.8 Moseley and the NOI group have also shown that people in pain often lose the ability to identify left or right images of their painful body part(s).
This research suggests that the brain has an altered image of itself. One way to help your client gain a more accurate picture of their own body is by performing right/left rolling patterns, similar to how a baby begins the movement experience. Rolling, is not only a movement strategy that is believed to improve proprioception, mobility and core function, but it is a great assessment tool to see where you should direct your soft tissue work.9 As your clients perform these movements, keep an eye out for any lack of symmetry between rolling from right to left and left to right.
There are four basic rolling patterns.
It is well documented that those suffering with chronic pain also have poor breathing patterns.11,19,24 It stands to reason that better breathing habits will yield a more functional core by improving diaphragmatic motor control and will also help in relaxing the client, thereby making it a very useful strategy in FA/CNSP cases. Learning to evaluate and correct poor breathing habits is an extremely important skill. I highly suggest Leon Chaitow's book, Multidisciplinary Approaches to Breathing Patterns Disorders, for further information.
Progressive muscle relaxation
PMR is an excellent way to reveal to the client that they are holding unnecessary tension within their muscles. Have your client either seated or lying on the massage table. After beginning with several deep breaths, instruct your client to alternately tense, hold, and then relax groups of muscles in his or her body. Direct your client's attention to the sensations of tightness felt while contracting and tensing the muscles. Your client's awareness should be dialed into the sensations of warmth, heaviness and relaxation in their body, as they review each muscle group individually, spending some additional time on problem areas. Instruct your client to perform this technique at home two to three times per day or at moments when they are feeling stressed or are about to perform an activity that they associate with pain.
The pain experience can be more complicated than just a physical problem. FA can perpetuate pain, limit activity, lead to further de-conditioning and ultimately lead to depression and isolation. Although great bodywork will be hugely beneficial to your FA/CNSP clients, a comprehensive treatment approach involving CBT might be necessary. Likewise, this specific set of clients must realize that they are not passive in this process. Meditation, better breathing habits and exercise are all terrific ways your clients can regain a sense of control over their pain.
Nicole Nelson a licensed massage therapist in Jacksonville, Fla. She has a masters degree in Health Science from the University of North Florida and is a certified Advanced Health and Fitness Specialist through ACE.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.