resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Term Limits: What's in a Word?
It was the French historian and philosopher Voltaire who once declared the Holy Roman Empire was neither holy nor Roman nor an empire.
Optimism = Compassion = Trust
A randomized clinical trial recently published online in JAMA Oncology examined how patients viewed their doctor based upon how the practitioner presented bad news to the patient.
The Tide is Rising in the Acupuncture Profession
Former President Ronald Regan said, "When the tide rises all boats float." The tide is rising for the acupuncture profession. Many forces outside the profession are helping the tides to rise.
Talking to Patients About Lumbar Facet Denervation (Medial Branch Neurotomy)
Lumbar facet denervation, more appropriately termed medial branch neurotomy (MBN), is a procedure that may be considered when patients suffer from recalcitrant non-radicular axial back and/or leg pain.
A View From the ER
The University of Western States has inked an innovative agreement with local nonprofit health system Legacy Health whereby UWS sports-medicine fellows can experience observational clinical rotations in emergency-room settings within the Legacy system.
Integrating Art with Clinical Practice for Patients with PTSD: The Artemis Project
Are you restricted by those one-on-one clinic dynamics? Why not join colleagues and clients in experimental group settings? Three of us volunteered to do just that in Austin on behalf of women veteranss from all branches of the service.
The Challenges of Integrating Eastern and Western Medicine
My Masters thesis was titled, "The Challenges of Integrating Eastern and Western Medicine," which highlighted several reasons why it is hard for these two worlds to mix.
Low Back Pain in Professional Golf: A Common Muscular Relationship
Every sport creates its own unique demands on the body. Some sports require such a myriad of body positions that assessing pathology is often difficult and unpredictable.
Functional Hip Impingement (Part 1)
Every time I sit down to write an article, I realize how much more there is to know about musculoskeletal pain. I also learn something new every time. (I want to give special thanks to Lucy Whyte Ferguson for assisting with this article.)
Applying the Thin Skull Principle
The "thin skull" principle, also known as the "you take your victim as you find them" principle, is a legal principle that can be summed up by the following statement.
How Much Do You Know About the Benefits of Birds Nest?
Edible bird's nest is the nest made by the Swiftlet bird of Southeast Asia that is usually prepared as a soup and prized in Chinese culture as a healthful delicacy.
PCOM Granted Regional Accreditation
Pacific College of Oriental Medicine (PCOM) recently announce it has received regional accreditation from the Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC). This achievement reflects five years of hard work on the part of faculty, staff, and students.
Turning a Blind Eye to History – and Reality
The American Medical Association is taking the Supreme Court's Feb. 25, 2015 decision exactly as it always does – by turning a blind eye to history, legal precedent and reality.
Medicine is Clumsy, Don't You Be
All medical systems have clumsiness in them. If the technique isn't, the practitioner is. Everyone in every form of medicine is striving to improve. That is why we call it practice.
Marijuana, Apathy and Chinese Medicine, Part 1
This article was written in response to the unheeded acceptance of marijuana as a harmless substance that potentially does good when used for the medical relief of pain.
Animal Acupuncture: A Case Study in the Treatment of Traumatic Injury in the Equine
The rise of animal acupuncture in the U.S. began in the early 1970's as a result of the work by members of the National Acupuncture Association in Westwood, Calif.
5 Tips for Using Pinterest to Market Your Practice
Pinterest is a very popular, but often under-utilized, social media platform where people can bookmark, or "pin," fun and interesting things from all across the internet.
A House Divided?
The American Chiropractic Association's House of Delegates voted on 30 resolutions at its annual business meeting in Washington D.C., but two in particular took immediate center stage due to their controversial nature.
The Acupuncturist's Problem
I want share with you some observations and insights into what seems to be the most common problem my colleagues in the acupuncture profession struggles with. If you also struggle with this problem, I hope you get a valuable "aha" moment from reading this.
5 Simple Steps to Create an Effective Marketing Calendar
In the educational experience of most healthcare practitioners, business and marketing are overlooked topics.
August, 2012, Vol. 12, Issue 08
The ELAP Project vs. The Seven Deadly Sins of Massage Education
By Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB
Author's Note: Ralph R. Stephens is a Director of the Alliance For Massage Therapy Education. This article represents his own, personal opinions and not those of the AFMTE.
One of the penalties of not participating in politics is that you will be governed by your inferiors." Plato
Part of political participation is being informed, and if you care at all about the future of our profession, I urge you to read the five page Entry Level Analysis Project (ELAP) description document at: www.abmp.com/downloads/ELAP_2012.pdf. The ELAP stated goal is to standardize educational hours, educational outcomes and improve "portability" – the ability to take licensure credentials from one state to another. All wonderful sounding things; who could be against them? I am not against any of them in principle, however I am extremely concerned about how they might be accomplished.
When you read the document, notice that the project's goal is to determine the minimum educational objectives and Knowledge, Skills and Attitudes (KSA's) needed for an entry-level therapist to pass a licensing exam (MBLEx) and give a "safe, competent" massage. Originally, it was just a safe massage. Competent was begrudgingly added due to the outcry of some concerned stakeholders. Never in the document will you find the term "Massage Therapy" or any other reference to being able to deliver therapeutic or clinical aspects of massage.
A new Job Task Analysis survey (JTA) is being conducted by the Federation of State Massage Therapy Boards (FSMTB) and it contains an add-on section to gather data for the ELAP. The analysis of this data will give more credence to therapists who have been in practice from one to four years and have performed at least 500 hours of massage. (Three years is where the high drop out rate begins.) Doing the math, this is one massage a day for two years or two massages a day for one year. This is what our associations feel is a "functional practice." (From the ELAP Description: "As shown by their persistence for this time, this group has demonstrated perseverance and the skills to develop a functional practice or work productively as an employee.") At two years out, would you define one to two massages a day as a functional practice?
Safety is not a significant problem in massage therapy. The incident rate of actual physical injury caused by massage therapists is miniscule. So, the standards determined necessary to prepare entry level therapists to pass the MBLEx, and give a safe massage, competently are going to be a very lowest common denominator. How is this going to elevate or improve our profession?
It appears the ELAP is a project designed to set another minimal entry-level standard. Why do it again? The data for entry-level KSA's is already on the table and just needs to be recognized and utilized. The danger here is, if this level of training, as defined in the project document, becomes our "standard," the potential exists to reduce/limit our scope of practice. This was tried already by the MTBOK project's scope definition, which fortunately has been mostly ignored. Particularly in states like Florida with a good scope of practice definition in their law, there is a lot to lose. What you might ask? Most likely, the casualty would be the ability to serve the public with the full potential of massage therapy. It could also lead to restrictions in our liability insurance coverage for "therapy," possibly requiring advanced certifications and additional insurance fees and riders to cover therapists doing therapeutic work. As you read the ELAP document, think about this, seriously.
Sadly, the need for the ELAP is based upon a fallacy. Then to begin to argue its minutia becomes an exercise in re-arranging the deck chairs on an adrift ocean liner. We do not need another blue–ribbon panel to set another standard or definition that ignores or papers over the fundamental problems of our profession.
The Real Problem
We have a real problem with substandard, inconsistent entry-level education causing poor quality massage to be delivered to the public. The problem with this low-quality massage training and its resulting low quality of massage practice is the unintended consequence of AMTA's policy of working to get 50 state licensure — no matter what the laws look like, with no attention paid to maintaining, much less expanding, our scope of practice or the regulation of entry-level training programs.
Over the past 15 years, the number of institutions offering entry-level massage training programs has expanded in recently licensed states. Most of these new programs were not traditional start-ups by long-time massage therapists who embodied the lineage of the field. For the first time, we saw the unfettered entry of for-profit career colleges and taxpayer-funded community colleges into our sector. It's simply supply and demand. The passage of new massage laws created new demand for the training required for licensure. These entities were in place with both classrooms and the Federal Student Aid eligibility to quickly add programs. The fact that there was not a population of trained massage therapy educators to teach these programs was not an issue, because the regulations for massage schools and instructors were lax or non-existent.
These institutions are opportunistic: they observe what's happening in the workplace and create or remove training programs according to what's hot and what's not. They have no long-term investment in the profession of massage therapy, as it's just another program to provide revenue. It's solely about the money and not about the lineage of massage therapy or who is being put out onto the street to practice it.
These developments have changed the landscape in ways we could not have imagined. In the rush to "elevate" massage to the status of a profession, AMTA (lately working with ABMP) has actually created a serious decline in the quality of massage services provided to the public (the unintended consequence). This problem is hard to get recognized, because most massage consumers don't know what a decent-quality massage treatment is like.
ABMP's latest massage consumer survey showed that 93% of massage clients were satisfied or very satisfied with the quality of massage they received. Does that mean massage therapists are doing a great job? No, it means most people have never experienced a good massage. To use a fast food analogy: a burger made from greasy, undercooked horsemeat is better than starvation, which is why a billion-dollar-a-year empire was able to be built on low-grade massage. Americans are so touch-starved that they will keep coming back for substandard massage, because it's better than not being touched at all.
How do we get the big players to own up to the respective roles they play in this situation? Neither ABMP nor AMTA have been willing to look at this. Not surprising, since students and graduatess from this sector have ballooned their membership rosters. They're both serving up "happy meals," and taking us on important-sounding trips to exotic lands named MTBOK, MOCC and now ELAP, all of which are distractions from the core problems. Despite their ongoing PR messages, these major organizations are interested fundamentally in their own well-being, and not the profession, much less the public. Actions speak louder than words.
At the very heart of the deterioration of massage quality delivered to the public is the lack of a trained teacher corps to staff all massage schools. To its credit, ABMP has created some basic teacher training seminars. However, they have also rejected as unnecessary and excessive the proposals for teacher education standards that have been developed by professional massage educators in a peer review process, which are based on teacher education standards recognized and used by a variety of other professions. Teaching theory and methodology is the issue here, not just knowledge of the subject(s) being taught.
The Seven Deadly Sins
Colleagues, here comes the real truth of the situation that no one has had the courage to put on the table until now. Standardizing the number of hours or the curriculum content (ELAP) will not improve educational outcomes as long as our massage educational institutions are allowed to:
The (ELAP) is a further diversion from the long and challenging work that will be needed to address these "sins." Two things are needed to "heal" the problem, money and moral conviction. ABMP, AMTA and FSMTB must be persuaded to give substantial and ongoing financial support to COMTA and AFMTE to assist them with their respective missions. COMTA because we need a strong accrediting agency dedicated to the field of massage therapy. That is the natural place for educational standards to live. AFMTE because their Teacher Education Standards Project (TESP) is the trail that the entire education sector must follow if we are to truly "elevate" the profession from the sad state in which it currently exists.
These organizations also need to take a public stand - an unequivocal position - that the operational practices listed in the "Seven Deadly Sins" are no longer acceptable in the massage therapy field; that we expect better from our schools and programs. They may not have the force of law, but such moral courage on the part of community leaders, consistently stated, can and will instigate a change in institutional behavior.
We must take up these challenges for the sake of the massage seeking public and for the lineage of our profession. Want to be part of the solution? Get involved. Thank you for your caring for our profession.
Click here for more information about Ralph Stephens, BS, LMT, NCTMB.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.