resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
What is a Discipline in Medicine?
In my now prolonged dialogue with physicians, one question emerges with enough regularity to deserve mention and naming: what is a discipline?
Get That Shoulder to Move: Restoring Internal Rotation
How many times have you mobilized, performed ART, Graston, FAKTR and PIR, and stripped a patient's posterior capsule, yet on re-exam, discovered it was still blocked?
Monoculture of the Mind: Part II
Cases are built within boundaries. Such bounds may be a program, event, activity or individuals. In this instance, a medical case has boundaries that include clinical interactions that are comprised of history, signs, symptoms, diagnoses, treatment plans and treatments.
Risk Factors for Heel Problems
Heel pain and gait disability are common occurrences in adults, often the result of thinning heel pads and a lifetime of exposure to heel-strike shock. One condition experienced by many people is plantar fasciitis.
One and Done: Keeping Patients From Vanishing After Just One Appointment
What happened to my 3:30 p.m. ROF? They may have rescheduled, but there are two common answers no one wants to hear: 1) "She called to cancel. I tried to get her to reschedule, but she refused." 2) "She no-showed.
AAAOM – The Beginning of the End (Part II)
In 2012, the AAAOM board members met in Chicago for their annual meeting. The goal was to come to a consensus on a long list of issues the AAAOM needed to work on including a functional board and budget.
Resilience is the New Longevity
Sometimes we must enter a room through one door and not another, even though they both lead into the same space. I am talking now of the recent cachet with the concept of "resilience" regarding health, chronic pain and longevity.
Successful Strategies in Integrating Acupuncture and Shiatsu in a Hospital Oncology Program
Colleagues from the Network of Researchers in Public Health in CAM recently published an article of interest to our Traditional Asian Medicine community.
Chiropractic Prevents ADHD? Research Shows...
Now that I have your attention, let me tell you what the latest study actually states. As you may have noticed, research over the past few years has begun to reveal that acetaminophen (the primary ingredient in Tylenol) is not as safe as once thought.
Creating Child-Friendly Clinics with ABT
The Zurich Dojo was scattered with toy ducks, dolls, trains, exercise balls and teddy bears during my recent pediatric workshop.
Green Tea Catechins Lower PSA, Other Biomarkers in Men With Localized Prostate Cancer
A 2006 study (Cancer Research) was the first human investigation to show that green tea catechins (GTC) are highly effective in reversing premalignant prostate lesions (high-grade prostate intra-epithelial neoplasia), an established precursor to prostate cancer.
AAAOM – Making Promises They Can't Keep
When the AAAOM first formed in 2007, their mission was clear: to support the profession through education, resources and legislative advocacy. The first years of the organization were filled with promise and hope.
Are You Guilty of Paternalism in Your Approach to Patient Care?
Einstein is purported to have said, "When a man sits with a pretty girl for an hour, it seems like a minute. But let him sit on a hot stove for a minute and it's longer than any hour. That's relativity." In some way, everything is relative to one's point of view.
Steven Rosenblatt: Birthing A Cross-Cultural Acupuncture Profession
The existence of a cross-cultural acupuncture profession in the United States, one that is legalized, licensed, supported by formalized, academic training and inclusive of non-Asian practitioners, is an important part of the medical landscape in this country and is responsible for improving the lives of hundreds of thousands of Americans.
Stress in the Modern Age: Impact on Homeostasis and What You Can Do (Part 1)
In 1926, Hans Selye first used the word stress in a biological context, referring to the nonspecific response of the body to any demand placed upon it.
Flexion-Intolerant Lower Back Pain (Pt. 3): Mobilization & Soft-Tissue Treatment
What is the biggest challenge to the chiropractor in treating discogenic pain? You have to completely reframe the purpose of your manipulation. It is rarely about unlocking a stuck segment at the disc involvement level; it is not about putting a joint back in alignment.
Collaboration for a Cause
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act strongly encourages the formation of multidisciplinary practitioner teams called Patient Centered Medical Homes (PCMHs) and Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).
News in Brief
Hamm Elected New President of the ACA; WFC / ACC 2014 Education Conference: Call for Papers; F4CP Recognizes Standard Process as $1 Million Supporter; Texas Chiro. College Begins Search for New President; League of Chiropractic Women Hosts Women's Success Summit.
The Healing Properties of Light: An Interview With Researcher Anna Cocliovo
This interview is with Anna Cocliovo, a light researcher and Acupuncturist in Arizona. During my own research in light, I came across the article she published for the American Journal of Acupuncture and sought her out as a result.
Leaving a Lasting Legacy: Donna Liewer
For the past 31 years, Donna Liewer has been on a personal mission "to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable." In her role as executive director of the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards, Liewer has accomplished that and much, much more.
Epigenetics: The Western Science Supporting Essence
Since the days of Darwin, western medicine has touted that our genes were set in stone, that our genetics were our destiny. We were told that the diseases that ran in our family were likely coming to us as well.
Why DCs Need to Understand the Principles of "Inclusive Design"
In the past few columns, I've written about the negative effects of prolonged sitting at work. I've attempted to make the point that prolonged sitting (or prolonged standing) takes a toll on workers. Now let's discuss a related issue: the concept of "inclusive design."
July, 2010, Vol. 10, Issue 07
CA Law Defanged
By Christie Bondurant
They expected "a walk in the park." Instead, the proponents of a California anti-prostitution law that targeted massage therapists found themselves trying to retreat out of a political minefield wondering how it all went so wrong.
As of press time, Assembly Bill 1822 is still under review by the state legislature. But, thanks to massive protest by the massage community and missteps by its backers, the bill has been radically altered and essentially defanged of the original structure that subjected massage therapists to unnecessary scrutiny by local law enforcement.
Introduced in February 2010, the original version of AB 1822 restored the authority of local police departments to issue work permits for massage therapists. That authority had been wrestled from the cops under a 2008 law that placed this power into the hands of the state massage organization, the California Massage Therapy Council (CAMTC).
The CAMTC was formed specifically to end a situation where massage therapists would undergo police checks in every jurisdiction they had clients. Under current law, a statewide certificate is issued by the CAMTC after it conducts criminal background checks and verifies the qualifications of those seeking permission to work legally. Once certified, a therapist no longer has to go from jurisdiction to jurisdiction seeking permission to work.
While opposition was apparent at the bill's introduction, the political firestorm that ensued began after a critical piece of data surfaced.
In a Feb. 21, 2010 letter to the bill's author, Assembly Member Sandre Swanson (D-Alameda), California Police Chiefs Association (CPCA) President Susan Manheimer wrote: "We recently did a random/regional sample of CAMTC applicants and found that 57% were known prostitutes, 32% were of unknown legitimacy and required further inquiry, and only 11% were legitimate operators."
The CPCA data never addressed the question of whether the massage council has actually certified unqualified people. Even so, the police group said that it was "completely unrealistic" to think that CAMTC could properly handle a massive volume of applications and instead called for local police screening.
Thus far, the only public statement alleging that CAMTC has let undesirables obtain authorization to work has come from a lobbyist for the Police Chiefs Association, John Lovell, who told Massage Today that there have been "several hundred certificants with past convictions."
This contention was strongly denied by CAMTC executive director, Ahmos Netanel, who said that Council data shows that police departments are the ones who have allowed criminals to pass background checks, not the Council.
Under the current state law (Senate Bill 731), criminal history checks are conducted at both the state and federal levels prior to the Council issuing certification, Netanel said.
"The CAMTC has never approved anyone who was not already approved through the DOJ (Department of Justice)," said Netanel.
Netanel also stated in a document calling for opposition to the bill: "CAMTC has rejected 3,424 applicants, who had passed background checks by local law enforcement, but when checked through CAMTC's process did not pass muster. In fact, so far 346 of those already approved locally were found to have criminal backgrounds and denied the statewide certification."
Mike Schroeder, a CAMTC board member who has been a major force in opposing the bill added: "It is patently obvious that there is no data, no research or anything resembling either.
"The CPCA continues to hide behind a facade; they obviously never expected anyone to challenge their blatant slander of the massage therapy profession."
Proponents Back Down & Scurry
As the details of AB 1822 became known, massive opposition began to build from the massage community through e-mails, letters, and published articles. Behind the scenes, Netanel and Schroeder lobbied key state legislators to change the bill. Eventually, both the public protests and private lobbying caused lawmakers to stop in their tracks and seek solutions from their opponents. As one opponent of the bill told Massage Today, "they expected a walk in the park, it turned out quite differently."
For a sense of the type of united front that came from the massage community, Massage Today posted a "Vote NO on AB 1822" e-mail form addressed to a state assembly committee voting on the bill along with the bill's author. Within days of posting the e-mail form, more than 1,500 e-mails were sent, catching the attention of the committee members and proponents of the bill.
Assemblyman Swanson and Chief Manheimer sat down with opponents of the bill including the CAMTC and the American Massage Therapy Association California chapter to begin discussions of amendments. After these discussions, the proponents backed down on its most controversial aspect: local police certification for work permits.
Amanda Whitehead of AMTA-CA thanked the massage community for their overwhelming support in influencing proponents of the bill. "Please know that your letters, e-mails, Internet postings and publicity have both influenced lawmakers and inspired those of us whose job it is to deal directly with the legislature," said Whitehead.
After the massage community's backlash and the bill's apparent unraveling, proponents quickly began to scurry out of the spotlight. And the once crucial element of the bill's urgency, the survey data, became the red-headed stepchild that no one wanted to claim, including the author of the bill, Assemblyman Swanson. In fact, various sources have reported that Swanson is deeply embarrassed by the bill along with the data that caused the uproar.
In an interview with Massage Today, he apologized to the massage profession for Manheimer's data.
"I apologize frankly for any misunderstanding," said Swanson. "I have received some personal e-mails from massage therapists who I've answered personally, clarifying any misunderstanding that this was an assault on the profession."
He also stated that he would question the data: "I would question it (the data) ... In terms of the legitimate massage therapists that I'm familiar with, they have pride in their profession. They have years of training and they ought to be respected."
And in response to our questions regarding the data, Manheimer claimed that a lobbyist was responsible for the calculations: "The CAMTC sent to one of our police agencies the list of applicants from the zip codes within that agency's jurisdiction and just outside the agency's jurisdiction. After reviewing the names, our lobbyist found that 57% were known prostitutes, 32% did not have enough information to make a determination, and 11% were known massage practitioners."
No additional detail was provided, including whether or not those applicants were ultimately certified by CAMTC to get work authorization.
Further, Manheimer's statement that the organization's lobbyist, John Lovell, compiled the data somewhat contradicts what Lovell said in an interview with Massage Today. While Manheimer states that Lovell calculated the percentages, Lovell stated that he believed the police chiefs association calculated the percentages.
In the April interview, Lovell said that he was uncertain but he "imagined" that the police group simply compiled the data into three piles: known prostitutes, unknown legitimacy and legitimate operators.
While the bill's language regarding local certification of individual massage therapists was removed, some are still concerned about the remaining language.
"CAMTC is adamantly opposed to AB 1822," Netanel said in an interview with Massage Today. "However, we are pleased with the direction it has taken."
The bill keeps language that adds two law enforcement members to the CAMTC including a Police Chiefs Association position and a Sheriffs Association position.
Another amendment includes an added section to strengthen enforcement against illegal operators of massage businesses. Section 4612.5 of the Business and Professions Code reads: "Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, any city, county, or city and county may require any person who administers massage for compensation, or who owns a massage establishment or business, to also hold a business license or a massage establishment permit or both."
As of press time, the bill is still under review by the legislature. Massage Today will continue to follow this story with up-to-date information regarding the bill's standing.
comments powered by Disqus