resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
What is a Discipline in Medicine?
In my now prolonged dialogue with physicians, one question emerges with enough regularity to deserve mention and naming: what is a discipline?
Get That Shoulder to Move: Restoring Internal Rotation
How many times have you mobilized, performed ART, Graston, FAKTR and PIR, and stripped a patient's posterior capsule, yet on re-exam, discovered it was still blocked?
Monoculture of the Mind: Part II
Cases are built within boundaries. Such bounds may be a program, event, activity or individuals. In this instance, a medical case has boundaries that include clinical interactions that are comprised of history, signs, symptoms, diagnoses, treatment plans and treatments.
Risk Factors for Heel Problems
Heel pain and gait disability are common occurrences in adults, often the result of thinning heel pads and a lifetime of exposure to heel-strike shock. One condition experienced by many people is plantar fasciitis.
One and Done: Keeping Patients From Vanishing After Just One Appointment
What happened to my 3:30 p.m. ROF? They may have rescheduled, but there are two common answers no one wants to hear: 1) "She called to cancel. I tried to get her to reschedule, but she refused." 2) "She no-showed.
AAAOM – The Beginning of the End (Part II)
In 2012, the AAAOM board members met in Chicago for their annual meeting. The goal was to come to a consensus on a long list of issues the AAAOM needed to work on including a functional board and budget.
Resilience is the New Longevity
Sometimes we must enter a room through one door and not another, even though they both lead into the same space. I am talking now of the recent cachet with the concept of "resilience" regarding health, chronic pain and longevity.
Successful Strategies in Integrating Acupuncture and Shiatsu in a Hospital Oncology Program
Colleagues from the Network of Researchers in Public Health in CAM recently published an article of interest to our Traditional Asian Medicine community.
Chiropractic Prevents ADHD? Research Shows...
Now that I have your attention, let me tell you what the latest study actually states. As you may have noticed, research over the past few years has begun to reveal that acetaminophen (the primary ingredient in Tylenol) is not as safe as once thought.
Creating Child-Friendly Clinics with ABT
The Zurich Dojo was scattered with toy ducks, dolls, trains, exercise balls and teddy bears during my recent pediatric workshop.
Green Tea Catechins Lower PSA, Other Biomarkers in Men With Localized Prostate Cancer
A 2006 study (Cancer Research) was the first human investigation to show that green tea catechins (GTC) are highly effective in reversing premalignant prostate lesions (high-grade prostate intra-epithelial neoplasia), an established precursor to prostate cancer.
AAAOM – Making Promises They Can't Keep
When the AAAOM first formed in 2007, their mission was clear: to support the profession through education, resources and legislative advocacy. The first years of the organization were filled with promise and hope.
Are You Guilty of Paternalism in Your Approach to Patient Care?
Einstein is purported to have said, "When a man sits with a pretty girl for an hour, it seems like a minute. But let him sit on a hot stove for a minute and it's longer than any hour. That's relativity." In some way, everything is relative to one's point of view.
Steven Rosenblatt: Birthing A Cross-Cultural Acupuncture Profession
The existence of a cross-cultural acupuncture profession in the United States, one that is legalized, licensed, supported by formalized, academic training and inclusive of non-Asian practitioners, is an important part of the medical landscape in this country and is responsible for improving the lives of hundreds of thousands of Americans.
Stress in the Modern Age: Impact on Homeostasis and What You Can Do (Part 1)
In 1926, Hans Selye first used the word stress in a biological context, referring to the nonspecific response of the body to any demand placed upon it.
Flexion-Intolerant Lower Back Pain (Pt. 3): Mobilization & Soft-Tissue Treatment
What is the biggest challenge to the chiropractor in treating discogenic pain? You have to completely reframe the purpose of your manipulation. It is rarely about unlocking a stuck segment at the disc involvement level; it is not about putting a joint back in alignment.
Collaboration for a Cause
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act strongly encourages the formation of multidisciplinary practitioner teams called Patient Centered Medical Homes (PCMHs) and Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).
News in Brief
Hamm Elected New President of the ACA; WFC / ACC 2014 Education Conference: Call for Papers; F4CP Recognizes Standard Process as $1 Million Supporter; Texas Chiro. College Begins Search for New President; League of Chiropractic Women Hosts Women's Success Summit.
The Healing Properties of Light: An Interview With Researcher Anna Cocliovo
This interview is with Anna Cocliovo, a light researcher and Acupuncturist in Arizona. During my own research in light, I came across the article she published for the American Journal of Acupuncture and sought her out as a result.
Leaving a Lasting Legacy: Donna Liewer
For the past 31 years, Donna Liewer has been on a personal mission "to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable." In her role as executive director of the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards, Liewer has accomplished that and much, much more.
Epigenetics: The Western Science Supporting Essence
Since the days of Darwin, western medicine has touted that our genes were set in stone, that our genetics were our destiny. We were told that the diseases that ran in our family were likely coming to us as well.
Why DCs Need to Understand the Principles of "Inclusive Design"
In the past few columns, I've written about the negative effects of prolonged sitting at work. I've attempted to make the point that prolonged sitting (or prolonged standing) takes a toll on workers. Now let's discuss a related issue: the concept of "inclusive design."
February, 2005, Vol. 05, Issue 02
Trust and Expectations
By Cliff Korn, BS, LMT, NCTMB
By now, you have probably already read this issue's top story outlining assertions of wrongdoing in the National Certification Board for Therapeutic Massage and Bodywork's (NCBTMB) election process.The news of this possible wrongdoing pains me; the situation is needless and is potentially evidence of a betrayal of trust by one of the most powerful and influential organizations in the massage therapy profession.
I know it also pains the volunteers who serve on the board and committees of the NCBTMB. Their organizational culture is not one that enjoys or allows much airing of dirty laundry; however, initial fact-finding indicates that Elizabeth McIntyre's complaint contains a certain amount of credibility since the NCBTMB's documented bylaws and policies have been vague in defining criteria.
In a nutshell, McIntyre maintains that although she is currently a sitting member on the Board of Directors (BOD), the NCBTMB nomination committee advised her that she does "not meet the current criteria for consideration" to run for a second term. According to McIntyre, this incident suggests that the NCB's nominations process is not fair or equitable, and further asserts that personal differences within the BOD affect the election process and that a "power play to control the BOD and the ballot process is occurring." If McIntyre's assertions ultimately prove accurate, the NCBTMB has exhibited an egregious breach of trust in the community it serves and will have outlived its useful life.
Of all the entities in our profession, the NCBTMB has long touted the highest of ideals and standards. Its statement of organizational purpose - its entire reason for being - is to foster high standards of ethical and professional practice in the delivery of services through a recognized, credible credentialing program that assures the competency of practitioners of therapeutic massage and bodywork. If the NCBTMB is indeed stacking the deck and manipulating the elections process to ensure a skewed result in populating its BOD, then it is the worst violator of its own standards. A grand house on a crumbling foundation cannot be expected to stand for long.
I am pleased that the NCBTMB took McIntyre's complaints seriously and investigated them. To the best of my knowledge, the NCBTMB nominating committee does not have substantial criteria to review for anyone desiring to run for the BOD. NCBTMB Bylaws state only that "Members of the Board of Directors, except for the public member, must: 1) be Nationally Certified in Therapeutic Massage and Bodywork (NCTMB), 2) have a minimum of three (3) years experience in the profession of therapeutic massage and bodywork, and 3) be in good standing with the NCBTMB." Period, exclamation point - that's it.
Unless there is a secret document in a safe somewhere, to my knowledge, the above passage is the sum and substance of qualifications for someone to sit on the BOD. It is also the only criteria mentioned in NCB's Articles of Incorporation, Bylaws, or Policies and Procedures. Without some clearly defined hurdles for prospective board candidates to clear, it is unfathomable to me that a nominating committee would find a sitting board member who has not been censured or sanctioned unqualified for re-election. Is the NCBTMB suggesting that it made grave errors in the past by letting McIntyre "slip through by mistake" and can correct that mistake by pulling her name from the ballot now? Does the NCBTMB think the certificant base is too stupid to realize that there might be better candidates for the position than an incumbent? Either suggestion makes me shudder.
As saddened as I am by this story, I am equally saddened by what has not been affirmed in all of this. I know many of the NCBTMB volunteers personally; I know them to be decent, honorable hardworking people doing their best to do right by the profession and the public. I also know that, contrary to McIntyre's allegations, the NCBTMB Board of Directors has no interfering capabilities in the nominating process or a desire to do so. The committee who reviewed the candidate's applications worked autonomously from the BOD. I know because I "lived in that house!"
I have chaired NCB committees, served as a director, and ultimately served as a chairman of the BOD. I know the culture; I know the effort those individuals expend on our behalf to make our profession the best it can be. I remember the untold hours I spent as chair of that organization dispelling myths about the NCBTMB. It is easy to suspect the NCB of myriad faults. It is a private, nonprofit, tax-exempt, autonomous, voluntary credentialing organization and as such, it doesn't have "members," or need to answer to or provide answers to massage therapists as a whole. I feel that the NCB has frequently accepted poor advice from its advisors and has chosen to use "legalspeak" to avoid real answers to real questions by real massage therapists. Coupled with a history of poor customer service, the NCB became an easy target for distrust. Those who choose to look, however, will find that the intent - if not the results - has always been for the highest good. I have personally never been more proud of any activities than those I did in support of the NCBTMB's goals.
The NCB certainly has not asked for my opinion of what to do about the situation it finds itself in now, but as I understand it, its recent problem-solving actions have gone a long way to ensuring that similar election questions are no longer raised. For one, it is in the process of completely revamping the entire election process from the bottom up. Giving McIntyre another chance to get on the ballot seems like a good first step to problem resolution. Developing real qualifications and criteria in policy that is made public is another step. If McIntyre's name is ultimately put on the ballot, it is then the responsibility of every eligible voter to determine if someone who took an internal matter and made it public while also campaigning for public support (an activity prohibited by NCB policy), can actually serve as an effective member of the team. I think not.
The NCBTMB has well over 80,000 certificants. A large majority of states regulating massage utilize the National Certification Examination (NCE). While it is technically a voluntary credentialing organization, the fact that many states require the NCE makes dealing with the NCBTMB an involuntary requirement. The NCBTMB arguably impacts more massage therapists than any other entity in our history. As such, the expectations are that the high ethics and standards espoused by the NCBTMB are reflections of how it functions internally. If it is it to remain in a position of authority and influence, the NCBTMB must earn the right to do so and accept the needs of the profession - not determine, then dictate them while breaking the rules it has set for itself.
The fact that it has recognized its systematic shortcomings and is actively arranging to revamp its systems to earn public trust, shows that NCBTMB's lofty ideals have not disappeared. McIntyre will get another shot at having her name on the ballot, as will all others who were previously reviewed by the NCBTMB's nominating committee. Hopefully, the form-letter language will be modified so that rejected candidates will understand that there were other, more qualified candidates to choose from, not that they didn't meet ambiguous selection criteria.
One of my favorite "curmudgeons" said recently, "In the absence of sufficient supportive information, the human brain will nevertheless construct meaning." I hope I have not fallen into that trap in my observations here. Scandal is a terrible thing for everyone, and this one certainly gets in the way of much of the good that the NCBTMB has done for the profession. If the NCBTMB satisfactorily exorcises this demon, I feel it deserves our support in fulfilling its ideals. If it chooses not to or fails to do so for other reasons, it will have not regained our trust and will likely wither and die.
Thanks for listening!
Massage Today encourages letters to the editor to discuss matters related to the publication's content. Letters may be published in a future issue or online. Please send all correspondence by e-mail to or by regular mail to:
Former editor of Massage Today, Cliff is owner of Windham Health Center Neuromuscular Therapy LLC. He is nationally certified in therapeutic massage & bodywork and is licensed as a massage therapist by the states of New Hampshire and Florida. Cliff is a member of the International Association of Healthcare Practitioners; a professional member and past president of the New Hampshire chapter of the American Massage Therapy Association; a certified member of the Associated Bodywork & Massage Professionals, Inc.; and a past chairman of the board of directors of the National Certification Board for Therapeutic Massage & Bodywork.
comments powered by Disqus