resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
An Integrated Approach to Chronic Pain
Findings from a unique Medicaid pilot project in Rhode Island involving high-use Medicaid recipients from two health plans were recently presented to the state's Department of Health, demonstrating stellar outcomes with regard to medication use, ER visits, health care costs and patient satisfaction.
Why I Quit Doing House Calls
My father was a chiropractor who did house calls, so when I became a DC, I figured doing house calls was part of the job. My March article recalled my experience as a small boy, accompanying my dad while he went to patients' homes to treat them.
Is the New Medicare Reporting Exemption Right for You?
What you've heard is not a rumor – there will be exemptions for providers of Medicare patients, with no penalties assessed for offices that do not do Quality Payment Program (EHR, PQRS, MACRA and MIPS) reporting.
Creating Good Business Buzz
What do patients really think about working with you? Rarely do you hear the whole truth. Those who improve may be candid in their gratitude.
Bill With Confidence: Learn What to Collect
Q: I am trying to understand what I may collect from my patient when there is insurance. Do I have to accept the amount allowed by the plan or may I collect up to my billed amount? Please note, I am not a member of any insurance plan.
Is It Time to Rethink Mental Illness? (Pt. 1)
Invariably, patients will ask their chiropractor about depression or various mental illnesses. Some practitioners will reflexively offer a cervical adjustment, suggest St. John's wort or contemplate a referral to a specialist.
A Daily Strategy for Heavy-Metal Detox
In modern society, we are constantly exposed to heavy metals such as cadmium, lead and mercury. These heavy metals have no essential biochemical roles in our body, and conversely, can cause us a great deal of harm if they build up to toxic levels.
Give Yourself the Digital Advantage
When you see this article in the print version of this issue and swear you read it already, don't be alarmed: you probably did. That's because by that time, the May issue will have been available online in digital format for three weeks.
Universal Design: Principles & Practice
In many respects, universal design serves as the core of ergonomics. It's also a good tool to use when designing a return-to-work program for injured and/or ill patients. Let's take a closer look at universal design and why it should matter to you and your patients.
A Major Role in Back Pain: The Multifidus
Back pain affects roughly 80 percent of the population at one time or another and is one of the leading causes of doctor visits.
News in Brief
ACA Adopts New Governance Model; ACA 2017 Awards; CCA Helps Calif. DCs "Share the Love"; $1 Million to Help Advance the Profession; D'Youville Raises the Bar on Anatomy Education; ErRatum.
Clearing Blocks: A Way to Improve Cosmetic Acupuncture
As a Five Element acupuncturist who teaches facial acupuncture classes nationally, I was surprised to learn that one of the basic principles I was taught in school is unfamiliar to most acupuncturists.
Raditation & Your Smartphone: Is it Worth the Risk?
If radial arteries could talk (and in my experience they can to some extent), they would say, "Step away from the smartphone." At least that is the message I am receiving loud and clear as I feel the pulses of many patients.
Eczema & Acupuncture: A Sound Solution (Part 1)
Eczema affects approximately 3.5 percent of the global population and is one of the most common skin complaints seen by dermatologists.
Women's Hormones: A Western & Eastern Perspective
Sometimes it may seem that you require a degree in medicine to understand hormones and how they function.
An Unexpected Diagnosis: The Result of Lacking Communication
A couple years ago I had a case that showed me the importance of open communication between health practitioners. We need to show up with less fear, and let go of our judgments so we can do better for the patient.
Balancing Spring Challenges
As the winter months come to a close and warmer spring weather appears, patients may begin to present with new challenging pattern presentations.
The Visual Error Scoring System: A Concussion Tool
Postural stability and oculomotor function are the most easily recognized physical indicators of neurologic motor dysfunction associated with concussions.
New Relationships, Old Trauma: AOM & Other Healing Strategies
Being in love is one the most beautiful and enjoyable experiences. Most of us are willing to pay almost any price to have that experience, and still often find it elusive or fleeting. Navigating the ups and downs of loving relationships are often challenging — even for the most psychologically balanced among us.
Taking the Chiropractic Message to the Press
"There is no better place on earth to have a news event," the National Press Club boasts, and it's easy to understand why: Every year, the 108-year-old Washington, D.C.-based organization hosts countless press conferences on the hottest topics impacting America and often the world.
June, 2001, Vol. 01, Issue 06
We Get Letters & E-Mail
By Editorial Staff
Editor's note: The first two letters reference "When Massage Meets Managed Care," from the February 2001 issue of MT. The article can also be viewed on line at http://www.massagetoday.com/archives/2001/02/04.html).
"I don't agree with pushing these managed care plans"
I really enjoyed your article in the February issue of Massage Today regarding massage therapy and insurance/managed care.I am a licensed massage therapist and have been practicing for 10 years. I have always been in a clinical environment, and I think it is a huge mistake for massage therapists to join these insurance plans.
Insurance is very destructive in a lot of cases. The insurance companies control the provider and the insured. They dictate the type of care people can receive and also dictate how much the provider receives for providing these services.
I think managed care will devalue the massage profession. If people truly understand the benefits of massage therapy, they will pay for it. Those who will only come if their insurance will pay are usually not interested in getting better or overcoming any type of problem, and they will drain you in numerous ways.
Why are we pushing this so strongly? I truly do not understand the mentality of the therapist who would want to join managed care. I have a very strong practice - completely booked with standing appointments (seeing 30 people per week); a waiting list; and all cash-paying clients.
I know there may be differences in the type of practice and type of clients other massage therapists have, but I still think we shouldn't be pushing these managed care plans. We should be able to have thriving practices simply by educating people and putting the appropriate value on the work we provide.
Lisa E. Kirk, LMT
"It's the game we should be preparing to play"
I received your February issue, and I have to say that your article on health insurance plans is right on track. What you have failed to mention is how the insurance game is typically played today by those already accepted into the "system." Inflated prices are commonplace in medicine, directly because of (in my opinion) these "modest discounts." And at one point I'm sure that they were just that: modest discounts. Doctors charged a fair price for their services, and people paid the doctor directly. Then came the third-party payor system and the progression of policy to what we see today. According to their tables (which are based on inflated prices), a 25% discount is modest. It is their world with their own benchmarks and standards. Doctors are forced to increase their rates disproportionately to get the insurance company to eventually pay a little more. We can see the evidence of this in the inflation rate of health care costs which are growing at 200% that of inflation (according to my memory from past news spots). It is commonplace for doctors to bill $300 and get paid $50 by insurance, while those paying cash get stuck with the whole bill.
It is clear that medical costs in general have become grossly distorted. However, we as massage therapists have not yet played the game of insurance long enough to become equally inflated. However, we have played the game of what the competitive market will bear, in which there is no room for grossly inflated prices. In order to survive financially and play their game, we too will have to become inflated in price to absorb the cost of discounting services. If we do play, we will become dependent upon the system, because no one outside of our contracts with the insurance company will be able to afford us. Moreover, the discretion of the therapist to appropriately treat the client will automatically be limited to what the prescribing physician orders and the insurance approves. For example, a physician writes a script for "massage" therapy for a patient's low back pain, and insurance approves the treatment for x # of sessions. Those who know little or nothing about holistic therapies will limit your ability to treat beyond the region specified (L1-L5). If you do treat beyond what was prescribed, your services will not be reimbursable if they "catch you committing fraud," and you will also have to contend with the potential legal consequences. It's precisely the same string that doctors complain of regarding HMO's -- the practitioner with the knowledge and skill isn't allowed to decide what is best for the patient.
There is another option, one that is becoming a major trend among many physicians: cash-based practices. Medical practices are firing billing departments, (on average it takes two full-time staff to handle insurance billing for every physician) cutting prices to fair/competitive levels, and going to cash payment for services rendered. In turn, the doctor provides patients (now customers) with a form detailing their diagnosis code, treatment codes, necessary physician information, and the amount paid by the patient. If patients desire to be reimbursed by insurance, they submit their claims to their insurance carrier and the carrier reimburses them directly. This is the type of game we can play where everyone wins, and it's the game we should be preparing to play as an industry.
Peter C. Kassner, ND, LMT
"I don't ever want to take insurance payments..."
I am a certified massage therapist in Virginia and just read the second issue of Massage Today. I agree with your article about "Massage and Medicine." (See the front page of the February issue, or access the article on line at http://www.massagetoday.com/archives/2001/02/06.html.) I had the option to participate in the networking program (access) and decided not to participate.
I am having trouble understanding why any massage therapist would participate. The only benefit a massage therapist gets is "possible" referrals. I am a business owner and started my business 1 1/2 years ago. The business has grown and continues to grow. I advertise some, but most of my new clients come from referrals, from other clients (word-of-mouth). With some hard work and patience, the referrals come and I don't have to take a cut in pay.
As a business owner, I can decide at any time who to give a discount or coupon to, for whatever reason. I would never agree to giving too many discounts, because I have monthly business expenses (office rent, phone, laundry, supplies, self employment taxes, etc.). I also earn my living solely on the profit of the business, so I cannot afford to give to many discounts. I opened my own business because I wanted to be the decision maker and not dictated to about policy and procedure.
I am also worried about HMO payments with the set price of $45 per hour (because that's the set price that all participating MTs have agreed to). Massage therapists participating in this sort of arrangement will never be able to get raises as they desire.
I only charged $45 per hour during my first year, but have since raised the price to $50 per hour. I will always try to keep my prices affordable for my clients. I pay out-of-pocket for my chiropractic care and at times, massages. I think enough about my health that I don't mind paying out of pocket for alternative health services. I don't expect any more from my clients than I expect from myself.
I don't ever want to take insurance payments because that will come with all kinds of problems (treatment dictation, three-month wait for reimbursement, etc.). I work extremely hard at my business. It's more than just doing massages. It's cleaning the office; washing the sheets; client chart paperwork; self-employment and tax paperwork; designing and printing my own brochures; newsletters; advertising; mailing birthday cards and newsletters to clients; etc.
I realize that $50 per massage sounds like a lot of money, but after my expenses and the time that I actually invest, I'm lucky if I'm making $12 per hour. I work too hard to make any less.
So honestly, what is the reason that MTs would participate in the networking program? Why not go out and get your own referrals, and charge what you think is fair to your clients?
Susan Cumpian, CMT
Reward Wellness, Not Sickness
I read your article in Massage Today concerning "Massage and Medicine. I was very taken with the article. As a massage therapist, I have many clients ask me if I take insurance. My reply is always, "No!" for the simple fact that I do not want to be dictated to. I work for myself on purpose. This way I have control over my business in its entirety. I know that Blue Cross and Blue Shield are involved in the alternatives now. Many organizations have approached me about belonging to their group. The reason I say "No" is because they want to tell me how to run my business concerning their clients, as you so aptly stated in your article.
I am 52 years old and have been practicing for 5 1/2 years. My practice is doing very well and I am grateful to all of my clients. If they choose to submit their time with me to their insurance carrier, I will give them a receipt for that purpose. This is as far as I am willing to go. People need to be responsible for their own health. Insurance carriers should be reimbursing clients for their wellness, not the other way around. It is just a matter of time before insurance companies reward people for maintaining wellness instead of rewarding them for sickness.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.