resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Right Back Where We Started?
More than 25 years after Judge Susan Getzendanner issued her historic opinion in the Wilk v AMA anti-trust case, evidence suggests that despite increasing collaboration between doctors of chiropractic and their allopathic medical counterparts, when it comes to organized medicine, we may be right back where we started.
The Conscious Evolution of Healing: Importance of Opening the Sensory Portals in Classical Chinese Medicine
The Chinese medical classics are not just clinical guides. They give advice; ways we can awaken more fully into conscious awareness.
Fight Colorectal Cancer With Folic Acid
CRC is the second most common cause of cancer mortality in the U.S. and Canada. Although genetic susceptibility plays a role in the etiology of CRC, dietary factors, including certain vitamins, have also been shown to influence the development of the disease in various studies.
Chiropractic Research in Review
Occupational LBP in Primary- and High-School Teachers; Treating MVA Complications With Chiropractic Care; Neck Pain: Immediate Effects of Active Scapular Correction; Taping Benefits Stride, Step Length in Fatigued Runners.
Helping to Create the Healthiest Generation
The imperative to create the "Healthiest Generation by 2030," envisioned by the American Public Health Association (APHA), was in full force at the APHA's 142nd Annual Meeting held in New Orleans from November 15-19, 2014.
Ringing in the Billing New Year
What are the new modifiers that replace modifier 59? Will they allow doctors of chiropractic to be paid for 97140, manual therapy, when done with chiropractic manipulation?
Trouble Down Under: San Zhen Therapy for Lower Jiao Issues
In the last several columns, I have discussed many clinical options for utilizing San Zhen or Three Needle Therapy. In this installment, I will continue this trend and discuss several foundational patterns which can be found in several very common clinical presentations.
AWB Makes a Difference in the Yucatan
We are in the sleepy town of Izamal, located about an hour from the Merida airport where our group arrived last night. Later that morning, on a bus winding through the dusty roads of the Yucatan, fourteen acupuncturists, two facilitators from AWB and two tour guides make their way to the small rustic town of Popola.
Three for One: The Cervical Distraction Test
Taking the time to do an exam is important, but it is time spent. The exam serves as a way to physically validate your clinical impression following a history and clinical consultation.
Taking the Freeze Out of Adhesive Capsulitis
Adhesive capsulitis or "frozen shoulder" is a relatively common condition resulting in severe shoulder pain and global loss of glenohumeral joint range of motion. Incidence of the condition is approximately 3 percent in the general population.
Age and Fertility: Why We Should Worry Less About Age and More About Overall Health
Recently, on one of the acupuncture alumni forums, the topic of age and fertility came up when a practitioner posted a question regarding a patient that was about to turn 40-years-old.
Acupuncture and its Place in the Integrative Healthcare Practice: The Need to Move from Modality to Profession
Acupuncture and oriental medicine (AOM) has grown and flourished from its inception thousands of years ago in China. In surrounding regions of Asia, AOM developed as a response to differing cultural, pathological, health and wellness care needs.
Movement Assessments: The DC's Sphygmomanometer
I think back to when I was going through chiropractic school outpatient clinic. I was embarrassed to have my family and friends come in for treatment because initial evaluations took three hours to complete.
The Way of Zen Performance Enhancement
Working with elite athletes and implementing various techniques to keep athletes focused and at their optimal performance for a sustained period of time includes incorporating various meditation techniques that counterbalance their sport-specific physical and mental demands, which is an important element of success throughout the years.
Environmental Toxins: Cause of Modern Illness, Part 2
In Part I of this article, we detailed the variety of environmental toxins assaulting our bodies. These include pesticides and herbicides; plastics; preservatives; cosmetics; gasoline additives, solvents and glues; and heavy metals.
Professionalism and Evidence-Based Health Care
Today's chiropractors are facing a conundrum with the Affordable Care Act and its health care reform requirements, including evidence-based practice and health technology assessment.
The Static Postural Pelvic Exam
I include a static postural analysis in my evaluation routine whether you are a patient in pain or an elite-sport athlete in training. In my day-to-day practice, I require patients to stand still while I "just look" at them.
Two for One: The Cervical Distraction Test
In today's healthcare system, diagnoses and treatment plans follow a western medical model - especially if you work with attorneys or insurance companies.
Show Up and Show Respect
I was recently asked about my chiropractic philosophy. My answer surprised my questioner.
The App Advantage: Get More for Less
You may have noticed the list of "app-exclusive" articles in the directory on the front page of the print issue and in the Table of Contents on page 4. You can't find these articles in print or even in our online archives.
I Felt it in My Fingers First
I'm not afraid to say it. Massage therapists make better acupuncturists. I'll tell you how I know, but first I have a question: What do a microcurrent device, a laser and a hippie massage therapist have in common?
News in Brief
While indignation may be your immediate reaction to H.R. 5780, the Protecting the Integrity of Medicare Act of 2014, the American Chiropractic Association suggests the legislation is just what the chiropractic profession needs.
How to Use Online Video as a Tool to Market Your Practice
Health care practitioners, including chiropractors, should consider online videos as a key element of their Internet marketing strategy. In the next three years, videos are expected to account for nearly 70 percent of all consumer online traffic, according to Cisco.
We Get Letters & Email
Rethinking Our Approach to Immunization; Coming Together for the Good of Our Patients.
Animal Acupuncture Gaining in Popularity
We have just finished the year of the fire hoarse and now it is time to spend some time alone, daydreaming and thinking outside the box in terms of where our profession is headed. The sheep person is well organized and creative so this should not be difficult to do.
April, 2001, Vol. 01, Issue 04
Networks: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly an Insider's View
By Editorial StaffThe recent proliferation of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) networks around the U.S. has stimulated much discussion and debate throughout the massage community. I have read numerous articles relating to this proliferation, most of which have taken a negative slant against what is often perceived as the "evil empire." Much of the commentary is reality-based and much is not. The following is an attempt to bring some clarity about the network industry to massage therapists.
The first HMOs in this country were developed in the mid-to-late 1970s. The managed care industry evolved throughout the 1980s and 1990s as a solution to escalating health care costs. Annual double-digit inflation was becoming the norm, and if health care costs were not contained, they would have exceeded the Gross National Product by the year 2004. The development of physician networks that agreed to accept a particular price for a particular product enabled risk-bearing entities, i.e., insurance companies, to lower inflation and maintain premium levels at a rate that employer groups could afford. There is no doubt that cost containment measures have helped employers to continue to be able to provide health benefits to their employees.
As the managed care delivery system, i.e., HMOs, PPOs, etc., penetrated markets from a regional perspective, physicians who had previously benefited from the escalating costs in the traditional fee-for-service model reluctantly contracted with these managed care entities. Most kicked and screamed the whole way. Specialty physicians saw significant reductions in reimbursement, while general practitioners and family medicine doctors, often referred to as primary care physicians (PCPs) became more valued within the health care continuum. Essentially, there was a shift in the balance of power and incomes and overall consumers benefited in terms of access to affordable health care.
Much has been written and reported about the problems with managed care -- some true, some not true, but often sensationalized for political reasons. Today, employers, Medicaid and Medicare embrace managed care delivery systems and, despite negative reporting, customer satisfaction remains high. Some HMOs are better than others, and today consumers have the opportunity to compare between plans viewing statistics regarding performance measures. As cumbersome as this system is, it is better than runaway inflation or socialized medicine. Managed care seeks to find an economy of scale and deliver quality health care at an appropriate cost. As long as there are large patient populations managed by risk-bearing entities, there will be networks of practitioners.
The landmark studies of consumer usage of CAM, conducted in 1990 and 1997 by David Eisenberg, MD from Harvard University, helped to initiate a groundswell of activity surrounding CAM activity and network design. Much of this movement was fueled by venture capitalists and entrepreneurs who hoped to cash in on this perceived groundswell of consumerism. Unfortunately, most of these venture capitalists and entrepreneurs knew nothing about healing space, attended therapy or relationship-oriented health care delivery. Most tried to overlay the traditional allopathic, procedure-oriented model onto a system oriented toward mind, body and spirit. In many cases, the result has been dismal, creating a disconnect between the holistic practitioner and the managed care system. For example, many network companies started a credentialing process with an application designed for the traditional physician. These application forms did not honor the massage therapist as a professional, and much of the application was not appropriate for the CAM practitioner. Strike One!
Many network companies employed the "build it and they will come" approach. Unfortunately, the massage practitioner had to jump through the many hoops of the credentialing process in hopes of attaining referrals. The managed care industry was going through a shakeout of its own. Pharmaceutical costs were rising at more than 20% annually and HMOs were losing money. Most companies paid only lip service to this thing called CAM. Managed care executives were focused on stopping the bleeding and could not give the appropriate attention to a truly integrated approach, with CAM, not to mention the American Medical Associations' disgruntlement with this wave of CAM consumerism. Politics got in the way, network companies had difficulty contracting with HMOs, and the promised referrals never materialized. Strike Two!
It soon became apparent that the HMOs did not have the money, the talent or the inclination to provide a covered benefit for CAM. With pressure from venture capitalists, the networks were forced to become a second-tier player. The only hope of these CAM networks attaining any revenues was through the advent of value-added or affinity products. These products would not be paid for by the insurer, but would represent a percentage discount to the plan member based upon some nebulous usual and customary charge. Unfortunately, this model did not recognize the difference between medically managed massage and non-medically managed massage, thereby laying ground for a new usual and customary charge if these benefits were ever to be covered by the insurer. Revenues to the affinity-based networks were far less than the venture capitalists expected, and the search for an exit strategy for the money guys became the main concern. Strike Three!
Presently, there are numerous CAM networks throughout the United States. These networks are differentiated by their various levels of management experience, commitment to the practitioners, contracts they serve, and understanding of the mindset of their contracted health providers. Some are interested in discounts, some are interested in assuring quality, and a few are interested in collecting data and proving efficacies. The challenge for the massage therapist is to figure out which networks will best serve the interest of their profession.
My experience is that health care is a unique product produced locally, consumed locally, and always best managed locally. Every region is significantly different in terms of health care cost, health care delivery, i.e., best practices, and health care politics. When reviewing networks, it is essential to determine who, what and where the promised processes will be managed. The most successful networks have evolved from the West coast and were born in the chiropractic management arena. In the early stages, these networks were paid pennies per member per month as an access fee to their product line. As competition increased, HMOs were willing to pay less and less for access to these affinity products. Today, the networks with the largest patient populations are willing to give free access to the HMOs in hopes of selling supplements and nutraceuticals, and willing to share those revenues with the HMOs.
These scenarios have evolved like this. The HMO typically assembles a CAM task force. The task force members may know very little about CAM and have little to no budgeted monies. In walks the national network company with slick brochures, offering access to their network for free, essentially touting a turnkey solution that can actually increase revenues to the HMO through profit-sharing of nutraceutical sales to the HMO members. The problem with this scenario is that the focus is on revenue generation for the plan and network, not collecting data or proving efficacy. In the pharmaceutical industry, this type of arrangement is considered illegal. If nothing else, it provides for a significant ethical dilemma. These arrangements also cut into revenues for those contracted practitioners who can sell and prescribe supplements within the legally defined scope of practice, i.e., acupuncturists. There is also a problem with perceived value. If the plan does not pay for the product, the perceived value is minimal. At the same time, this national network might provide referrals for the massage therapist. If you can live with the fee schedule, and need new clients, this model may help you in the short term. However, the long-term ramifications can be significant if this model, which is financed through nutraceutical sales, not medical management fees, becomes dominant. Once again, it is illegal in the allopathic world for those who prescribe to financially benefit from the prescription.
The HMO world is highly regulated. Each state has a department of insurance (DOI) whose mission is to protect consumers. It is likely that some of these arrangements are and will be frowned upon by the DOI bureaucrat. Managed care organizations are licensed to manage care, not to sell supplements. When considering a network, it is important to know how they generate revenues.
The bottom line is that not all networks are created equal. In a perfect world, all services would be paid for by the patient. Every town in America has a few physicians who no longer accept insurance. Their reputations are so great that patients who are able to pay out of pocket, flock to them to receive the type of care they deliver. If only all Americans had plenty of disposable income, there would be no need for insurance. However, this is not the reality. Most physicians have to deal with the bureaucracy of managed care in order to make a living. Many massage therapists deal exclusively with cash-only clients. However, as we continue to train and license more and more therapists, and the benefits of massage become more commonly accepted throughout America, the prudent therapist will choose to do business with quality networks. The following are some guidelines to consider when contracting with a network:
Does the network perform true credentialing that will stand up to the scrutiny of the medical community, regulatory authorities, accreditation boards and managed care executives? For example, do massage therapists require extensive experience and training, vs. state or nationally mandated minimum requirements for licensure or certification? What are practitioner selection criteria, and do processes ensure quality vs. quantity? Is the group contracting with everyone in your area and are consumers truly protected by the process? Does the network support advancement of your profession's practice standards by promoting stringent credentialing standards designed to identify quality practitioners? Does network require a meeting and site visit to discuss your practice philosophy and qualifications? Is the network application targeted toward your profession, or is it simply a standard medical doctor application?
Types of Practitioners
What types of practitioners are included in the network? Are they licensed and regulated modalities, and will they ensure legitimate acceptance within an integrative medicine model? If there are practitioners on the panel who are not regulated by the state, how are these providers credentialed?
Contracts in Place
Does the network have any contracts in place that will drive referrals? What is the geographic area the network covers, and how many members does it cover? What is the financial arrangement between the health plan and the network?
Does the network require collection of encounter or patient data that is shared with primary care physicians and will document outcomes and efficacies? Is communication between physicians and holistic practitioners supported and encouraged?
Scope of Contract
Is practitioner agreement comprehensive enough to support future covered benefit requirements? Does it contain language that is mutual holding you harmless and not requiring exclusivity? Will the contract withstand the scrutiny of HMO regulatory authorities?
Is there a fee schedule and if so what is it? Is medically managed massage differentiated from wellness massage? Or, is there a blanket 15-20% discount off charges? Is reimbursement driven by modality or time spent with patients? Where do financial incentives lie to protect your relationships with clients? If the network is based upon a discount off charges, the likelihood that members will shop price instead of quality remains predominant.
Is the organization available to support you and your profession with reimbursement and managed care integration issues? Does the network charge a fee to join...if so how much and why? What are the long-term goals and mission of the network? Are they committed and knowledgeable about your professional field of practice?
How will network providers be marketed? Is there a directory? If so, how often is it distributed and updated? Is there online directory access?
In closing, the network is a business model that can bring value to health plan members and contracted massage therapists. However, in order to minimize future conflicts, it is important that each massage therapist practices due diligence when considering any business opportunity.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.