resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Let the Patient Tell Their Story
Often when a patient presents with an injury, they want to tell their story. People by nature like to talk about themselves, particularly when they're worried about their health.
News in Brief
NBCE Launches Computer-Based Testing Era; California Chiropractors Get Expanded DOT Exam Privileges; New Jeff Hays Documentary.
Medicalization and Mindfulness
The past several years have seen a veritable explosion of research on mindfulness. Research abstracts we've published in each issue of Health Insights Today under the heading "Mind-Body News" have increasingly reported on studies about mindfulness interventions.
A Glimpse Into China's Top Brain Hospital
The sounds of the city pass through the open window are overwhelming the microphone - car horns, construction machinery - and then there's the family at the adjacent bed talking loudly on cell phones, yet you can still hear the faint beep of our patients monitoring equipment.
History of Animal Acupuncture: Part II
In Part I of this article, I had gone back to 1969 and tried to describe the atmosphere and events of that year that engulfed many of the younger generation, some who were all the core members of the National Acupuncture Association.
If You Get a Request for Records, Respond!
In our previous two articles, we discussed two of the main reasons for denial when chiropractic records are reviewed by Medicare contractors.
The Truth About Herbs
I appreciate the effort and research put into the article written in the June issue of Acupuncture Today regarding pesticides and Chinese herbs.
Healing Community Trauma in Israel and Palestine
It's the beginning of August and Israel and Hamas have just agreed to a 72-hour ceasefire after a month of brutal fighting. In the last four weeks, 1,830 Palestinians and 67 Israelis have been killed.
A Healthy Dose of Failure is Vital to Your Success
As an acupuncturist I tend to see people after they have already suffered for years and "tried everything." They are so desperate for some relief that they want to know everything about how to get better, right now.
The Science Behind Happiness
Are you happy right now? Whether yes or no, there are a myriad of reasons why you feel that way. A whole academic discipline has developed to find out what causes or obstructs happiness, and how to amplify it.
When Big Pharma Meets Chinese Medicine
Earlier this year, Bayer made a media splash with their decision to buy the Dihon Pharmaceutical Group Co., a Chinese TCM manufacturer.
Thoughts to Live By
When speaking to your patients about their health make sure to ponder the following points and have them assess if they are making themselves even more sick by the thoughts they have about life. Are these some of the traits and thoughts that your patients might have?
Help Secure Our Future by Sharing It
The National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE) conducts one of the most comprehensive surveys of the U.S. chiropractic profession every 4-5 years.
Get Ready For AOM Day
This year, AOM Day 2014 falls on Friday, (October 24th). This is a great opportunity to make your AOM Day celebration or event even bigger by extending it throughout the weekend!
Thoracolumbar Syndrome: The Great Mimic
The thoracolumbar junction is a common area of joint dysfunction. The most obvious cause is dysfunctional breathing or lack of diaphragmatic breathing. Treating this breathing problem will ultimately be the long-term cure for the syndrome.
The Problem With Prolonged Sitting
We need to constantly talk to our patients about spending less time sitting and about what can go wrong with poor sitting postures. The fact is we sit too long in repetitive malpositions.
MPA Media Wins Seven Publishing Awards
MPA Media, publisher of Acupuncture Today, among other titles, has been recognized for editorial and design excellence with an unprecendented seven publishing awards by the ASBPE, the nation's largest organization for business-to-business publications.
A Commonly Missed Spinal Fixation: The Upper Lumbar Spine (Part 1)
When we think of lower back pain, we tend to think in terms of the lower lumbar spine and the SI joint. These joints and their discs are obviously important. However, we tend to miss fixations that occur just above – in the upper lumbar spine. Three questions come to mind: 1) Why is the upper lumbar spine so important? 2) Why do we miss the fixations here? 3) How can we adjust them?
Uncle Sam Needs You
Scrutiny into the Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA) continues to grow after efforts to reform the DVA by the former Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Eric Shinseki, were deemed "a stunning period of dysfunction" by Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.).
Rethinking GMO: Less Panic, More Context
Some of you may have noticed that after writing parts 1 and 2 of “Genetic Modification of Organisms for Human Consumption” a while back [Nov. 15, 2013 and Jan. 1, 2014 issues], part 3 never appeared.
The Spirit of the Point
After receiving a large amount of positive feedback on my San Zhen Protocols series, I have decided to focus this article on some relevant clinical aspects of acupuncture therapy prior to moving on to San Zhen Protocols III.
June, 2004, Vol. 04, Issue 06
Setting the Record Straight: Massage Gets a Bad Rap in National Report
By Rebecca J. Razo
Over the years, the massage profession has been no stranger to adversity. Many battles have been fought, and won, to protect the reputations of the profession and massage professionals throughout the country.Fortunately, an increasing number of studies and news reports have helped validate massage and other forms of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in treating pain and dysfunction. (See the top story in this issue: "Newsweek Validates Complementary and Alternative Therapies for Back Pain" www.massagetoday.com/archives/2004/06/01.html) With all of the positive aspects of the advancing massage profession, it can be disheartening when media reports indict massage as a harmful practice with little or no supporting evidence.
Such was the case in April 2004, when a short segment ran on national television suggesting that massage can be dangerous. The segment, which was written, produced and distributed by Ivanhoe Broadcast News - a health news-gathering service that produces daily media reports - was subsequently posted on several Web sites.1 One report, "Massages Could Cause More Pain Than Relief," ran on a major Southern California network with the following introduction: "People often feel better right after a relaxing massage, but many people leave the table feeling even worse. Experts say what you don't know about massage may cause more pain than relief."2
The feature discussed the case of Mary Schreiner, who had sought massage after suffering injuries in two major accidents. Schreiner claimed she felt fine during and immediately following massage, but that the treatments ultimately aggravated her injuries; in the end, Schreiner received cortisone injections to manage her pain.1,2
The piece quoted only one expert, Dr. Robert Gotlin, a physical rehabilitation specialist with Beth Israel Medical Center in New York City, who made three blanket statements in relation to massage, including that 15 percent of massage patients need corrective treatment following massage; thin people should avoid deep-tissue massage because of potential injury; and a client's likelihood of receiving a safe massage is better from a "therapist with credentials from the American Massage Therapy Association."1,2
In an initial phone interview, Dr. Gotlin told Massage Today that his true message was not made clear in the television segment, and that he was not given the opportunity to proofread the piece before it went to production3 -- a statement Stacie Overton, Director of Medical Programming for Ivanhoe, vehemently denies. "We fact-check everything we do," Overton said. "If he had a problem, I wish he had said something ... if [he thought the piece] was presented poorly."4
Dr. Gotlin indicated that the segment was originally intended to address what he perceives is a problem in the massage profession. "The impetus for this piece is the recent increase in storefront 'pay-by-the-minute' massage centers," he said. "For the hundreds of patients seen monthly for complaints of musculoskeletal pain ... [an] increasingly common modality tied to pain symptoms is storefront 'pay-by-the-minute' massages."5 But Overton denies the piece was ever intended to cover massage mishaps in storefront-type operations. "I would have never accepted that story," she said.4
When queried about his claim that 15 percent of massage patients need corrective treatment, Dr. Gotlin told Massage Today that his statistic was derived from unofficial, nonscientific assessments of thousands of patients from his private practice over the past two to three years. "This was a practice comment," he said.
However, transcripts of Ivanhoe's original interview, which were fact-checked and approved by Dr. Gotlin prior to production, show-- although he openly admits his conclusions are based on "trial and error" evaluations of his own patients -- that Dr. Gotlin never clarifies his statistical assessment is based on those same in-office patient evaluations; consequently, this omission resulted in an innacurate depiction of massage injuries.6,7,8
Moreover, Dr. Gotlin, who claims to see roughly five to six patients a week for injuries following massage, agreed that his patients usually have pre-existing injuries that are merely exacerbated -- not caused by -- massage.3 The feature never makes this point clear.
In reality, it is "rare for a well-trained massage therapist to give a bad massage," remarked AMTA President Laurel Freeman. "There are very few malpractice claims filed against massage therapists for injury."9 Moreover, the number of documented injuries is extremely low.
According to a study conducted by massage educator Keith Eric Grant, PhD, and published in the October 2003 issue of the Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies: "There are extremely few reported cases of injury related to massage within the indexed health care literature. While statements have occurred in newspapers that would seem to indicate that massage has a high potential and probability for causing injury, such anecdotal statements have no support in the medical literature or in insurance statistics."10
And a study published late last year in Rheumatolgy indicates that although "massage is not entirely risk free ... serious adverse events are probably true rarities."11
"I seriously question the judgment if not the ethics of [Gotlin's] pronouncements to the media," Dr. Grant said. "If Dr. Gotlin had clinical observations to report, doing so by a journal article or letter to the editor would have been a fully appropriate and useful contribution to the ongoing professional dialogue and development of the massage profession." Dr. Grant further noted that Dr. Gotlin's statements were made "in a manner potentially misleading to the public."12
Still, Dr. Gotlin stressed his support of massage therapy when properly indicated, and affirmed that his concern is for those who self-treat with massage prior to seeking appropriate medical care for pre-existing injuries. "For those who are without pain and wish the comforts of soft-tissue massage ... this is not the population I am speaking of," he said. "It is those who have complaints of neck or back pain accompanied by arm and/or leg pain, which manifests at night, or pain along with muscle weakness ... conditions which should undergo a medical evaluation before embarking on any therapy.
"Massage therapy may be an excellent modality choice if not contraindicated," he continued. "Many patients are not [told] to seek medical advice by the storefront massage therapist. In fact, there is usually no discussion of any related symptoms."5 Yet, Dr. Gotlin's support of massage therapy was not a point made central to the feature that aired.
James Waslaski, international lecturer on orthopedic massage, chronic pain and sports injuries, believes that massage often receives negative press because of ongoing "turf wars" between health care professionals, and affirms that "many advanced disciplines within [the massage] profession have a very low chance of making an existing injury worse.
"I do recommend that people become certified in advanced [massage] disciplines ... to assure that proper assessment is done prior to treatment. By referring out [to other qualified therapists], certain complicated conditions ... would not become exacerbated by massage treatments. In fact, many times for soft tissue injuries, muscle relaxants and cortisone injections will only mask the patient's symptoms instead of treating the underlying structural imbalance causing the pain," Waslaski said.13
Another of Dr. Gotlin's claims was that thin people should not receive deep-tissue massage. "The most common body habitus seen with complaints of increased symptoms with deep massage is the ectomorph. Those who are thin may suffer the greatest ill effects of deep-tissue massage, likely due to the close proximity of the massaging hands to inflamed nerves and muscles," he said.5
But according to Waslaski, "deep tissue massage can indeed be performed safely on thin individuals." Waslaski affirms that most orthopedic massage instruction stresses the importance in teaching massage to remain "always pain free," which may involve "superficial to deep, myofascial spreading routine, avoiding bony landmarks to increase blood flow to ischemic areas ... gentle trigger point techniques to referral pain patterns in short muscle groups and gentle stretching ... to assist the body back to a state of balance.
"In my opinion, muscle groups shorten because of repetitive use or poor postures," he continued. "It is our role to lengthen those short muscle groups in a pain free fashion. We should never cause pain in our treatments, and [must conduct] a thorough assessment of [the] patient prior to doing the treatment," Waslaski added.13
Freeman agrees. "Thin people have skin and muscles just like people who are heavier. The more important question is: 'What is the person's sensitivity level?'"9
Although Dr. Gotlin is on record saying that those seeking massage should ask if "the therapist [is] certified by the AMTA,"7 he amended his statement to Massage Today, stating instead that consumers should seek a massage therapist "who is certified/licensed by an organization such as the AMTA."5
He also wants the public to know that his intentions were noble: "The intent of ... my media pieces is to 'advise' consumers ... to increase awareness of the indications/contraindications and risk/benefit ratios for the many therapeutic options available," he said. "I am an advocate and believer in massage therapy."5
Although some may construe this report as a setback to the massage industry, Freeman emphasizes how far the profession has come over the past several years. "Massage has been growing at an incredible rate," she said. "In the last seven years, AMTA's consumer surveys have shown the percentage of American adults receiving massage jump from 8 percent to 21 percent; the number of articles written about massage have gone from 3,700 per year to over 15,000; and the massage profession is listed in the American Medical Association's Health Professions Career & Education Directory."9
Editor's note: Due to the transient nature of the Internet, some links may no longer be accessible.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.